Points of Intersection for Two Logarithmic Spirals

706 Views Asked by At

So I have two logarithmic spirals in parametric form $$ x(t) = ae^{bt}\cos t \\ y(t)=ae^{bt}\sin t $$ and $$ x'(t) = \alpha e^{\beta t}\cos t \\ y'(t)=\alpha e^{\beta t}\sin t $$ With $\beta$ and $b$ having opposite signs so the spirals grow in opposite directions. Setting the $x$'s and $y$'s equal and solving for $t$ I get $$ t = \frac{1}{b-\beta}\ln\frac{\alpha}{a} $$ Evaluating $(x(t),y(t))$ for that value does produce a single point of intersection for the two spirals, but I can't seem to find the general form that would give all the points of intersection.

I've fiddled around with it in polar form, both as $r(\theta)$ and as $\theta(r)$, and solved for the intersection points, but I couldn't figure out the general form in those cases either. (I tried integer coefficients, and multiples of $\pi$ and $2\pi$ to no avail.)

Eventually I realized I would prefer the parameterized approach because it'll be easiest to work in terms of $t$.

But I still feel lost in how to find the other points of intersection.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

In this reply I will give a solution for the intersection of two logarithmic spirals.

Consider two spirals in the complex plane with different angular regions, e.g.,

$$ z=e^{(b+i)u}\\ w=e^{(\beta+i)v} $$

and we seek all the points where $z=w$. We can expand these and separate the real and imaginary parts to obtain

$$ e^{bu}\cos u=e^{\beta v}\cos v\quad \quad \quad (1)\\ e^{bu}\sin u=e^{\beta v}\sin v\quad \quad \quad (2) $$

If we multiply (1) by $\sin u$ and (2) by $\cos u$ and subtract, we obtain

$$0=e^{\beta v}[\sin u\cos v-\cos u\sin v]=e^{\beta v}\sin(u-v)\quad \quad \quad (3)$$

Similarly, if we multiply (1) by $\cos u$ and (2) by $\sin u$ and add, we obtain

$$e^{bu}=e^{\beta v}[\cos u\cos v-\sin u\sin v]=e^{\beta v}\cos(u-v)\quad \quad \quad (4)$$

Equation (3) tells us that $(u-v)=n\pi$. Equation (4) tells us that $n$ must be even since $\cos n\pi$ alternates in sign, but (4) must be positive. So we conclude that

$$v=u+2n\pi$$

(assuming that $v$ the larger of the two).

Finally, going back to the beginning, we must also have $|z|=|w|$, and therefore

$$e^{bu}=e^{\beta v}=e^{\beta(u+2n\pi)}$$

so that

$$ u=\frac{2n\pi\beta}{b-\beta}\\ v=u+2n\pi $$

The figure below shows a sample calculation (cleverly chosen to give simple results). Here

$$ b=\frac{2\ln\varphi}{\pi},\quad \text{the golden spiral}\\ \beta=\frac{\ln\varphi}{2\pi}\\ $$

$$ u=\frac{2n\pi}{3}\quad \{120,240,360,480,600,720^\circ...\}\\ v=\frac{8n\pi}{3}\quad \{480,960,1440,1920,2400,2880^\circ...\} $$

enter image description here

0
On

You are incorrect when you say With β and b having opposite signs so the spirals grow in opposite directions. This parameter is called the flair coefficient, its sign indicates whether the spiral is growing or shrinking, but both evolve in the anticlockwise direction. Thus it's quite possible that they do not intersect at all other than at their mutual starting point of $\theta=0$.

You should run some plots.