Proper notation for partial derivative

125 Views Asked by At

I'm writing some notes on differential calculus over normed spaces and I'm having some trouble finding the appropriate notation for partial derivatives. Here's what I mean:

Derivative of a map between normed spaces. If $f:E\to F$ is a map between normed spaces $E$ and $F$ over the same field $\mathbb{K}$, I say it is differentiable at $a\in E$ if there exists a continuous linear map $T\in\mathcal{L}(E,F)$ such that $$\lim_{h\to 0}\frac{\lVert{f(a+h)-f(a)-Th}\rVert_F}{\lVert{h}\rVert_E}=0.$$ It is easy to see that if $T$ exists then it is unique. I call it the derivative of $f$ at $a$, and denote it by $\mathrm{d}_a f$. The reason I choose to use this notation and not the (more common) $\mathrm{D}f(a)$ is that, since the derivative is itself a map, it can take inputs $v\in E$, so in the second case I would have to write the more awkward $\mathrm{D}f(a)(v)$ instead of the more comfortable $\mathrm{d}_a f(v)$ for the image of $v$ under $\mathrm{d}_a f$. See this answer from Qiaochu Yuan for more context.

Partial derivatives. Let $E=E_1\times\cdots\times E_n$ be a product of normed spaces and let $F$ be another normed space. Let $f:E_1\times\cdots\times E_n\to F$ be a map, which can be written as $(x_1,\ldots,x_n)\mapsto f(x_1,\ldots,x_n)$, where $x_i\in E_i$ for $i=1,\ldots,n$. Let $a=(a_1,\ldots,a_n)\in E$ be fixed. If the map \begin{align*} E_r&\to F\\ x_r&\mapsto f(a_1,\ldots,a_{r-1},x_r,a_{r+1},\ldots,a_n) \end{align*} is differentiable, I say that its partial derivative with respect to to the $r$th variable at the point $a$ is the derivative of the above map at the point $a_r$.

Question. As I said, I can't decide what notation to use here for partial derivatives. Some authors use $\mathrm{D}_r f(a)$ or $\partial_r f(a)$ to denote it, but we run into the same "problem" I mentioned before (the partial derivatives here are itself linear maps). The most comfortable notation I have found so far is $\partial_r f\rvert_a$, but it still does not convince me, because I want to have a very similar notation for the case $E_1=\cdots=E_n=\mathbb K$, where we get the classic partial derivative by identifying the derivative with its value at $1\in\mathbb K$: $\partial_r f(a) = (\partial f/\partial x_r)(a) = \partial_r f\rvert_a (1)\in F$.

Any help or suggestion is very appreciated.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

There are a few standard notations for partial derivatives of maps between normed spaces:

Df(a)(v) or Df(a).v for the total derivative at a, as a linear map. ∂rf(a) or ∂f/∂xr(a) for the partial derivative with respect to the rth variable. ∂rf|a to emphasize that this is the derivative of the "restricted" map xr ↦ f(a1, ..., ar−1, xr, ar+1, ..., an).

So for your example, I would write: ∂f/∂xr(a) = ∂rf|a(1)

The notation ∂rf|a has the advantage that it's consistent whether xr ranges over K or a general normed space Er. The notation ∂f/∂xr(a) is more standard when xr ranges over a scalar field (like R or C), but is a bit inconsistent when Er is a normed space.

Either notation is fine, so I would choose based on what you're emphasizing or what your audience would find most familiar.