Prove that 2 inner products are related like this when they are equal for orthogonal vectors

77 Views Asked by At

I'm working through Axler's "Linear Algebra Done Right", but I'm stuck on Exercise 6.B Q11:

Suppose $<.,.>_1$ and $<.,.>_2$ are inner products on $V$ such that $<u,v>_1 = 0 \iff <u,v>_2 = 0$ Prove that $<v,w>_1 = c<v,w>_2$ for some fixed $c>0$ for any vectors v and w.

I've been able to simplify the problem as so:

Let $k$ be a scalar such that $u-kv$ is orthogonal to $v$, so we have

$$ \frac{<u,v>_1}{<u,v>_2} = \frac{<kv,v>_1 + <u-kv,v>_1}{<kv,v>_2 + <u-kv,v>_2}$$ $$ = \frac{<v,v>_1}{<v,v>_2}$$

So it would suffice to show that $||v||_1 = c||v||_2$. However I'm stuck on how to show this.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Thanks to Gram-Schmidt you can take a basis $\{v_1,...,v_n\}$ which is orthonormal with respect to the first inner product. Now, thanks to orthonormality, you have: $$<v_i+v_j,v_i-v_j>_1=<v_i,v_i>_1-<v_j,v_j>_1=1-1=0$$ Since $<.,.>_2$ has the same orthogonal vectors $v_i+v_j,v_i-v_j$ are also orthogonal w.r.t $<.,.>_2$. So: $$0=<v_i+v_j,v_i-v_j>_2=<v_i,v_i>_2-<v_j,v_j>_2 \Rightarrow <v_i,v_i>_2=<v_j,v_j>_2=c$$ So, $\{\frac{v_1}{c},...,\frac{v_n}{c}\}$ is an orthonormal basis w.r.t the second inner product and, by linearity, for every vectors $v$ and $w$ you have $<v,w>_1=c<v,w>_2$