Prove that $hxyz$ is a perfect square.

87 Views Asked by At

From The British Mathematical Olympiad, Paper 2, 1998, Question 3:

Suppose $x, y, z$ are positive integers satisfying the equation $\frac{1}x - \frac{1}y = \frac1{z}$ and let $h$ be the highest common factor of $x, y, z$.

Prove that $hxyz$ is a perfect square.

Prove also that $h(y−x)$ is a perfect square.

Here is my attempt for part 1:

$\frac{1}x - \frac{1}y = \frac1{z}$

$yz-xz = xy\\z(y-x) = xy$

$x = c_1h\\y= c_2h\\z = c_3h$

$c_3h(c_2h-c_1h) = xy\\c_3h^2(c_2-c_1) = xy\\h^2(c_3(c_2-c_1)) = xy\\zh^3(c_3(c_2-c_1)) = hxyz\\h^4(c_3^2(c_2-c_1)) = hxyz$

And for part 2:

$h(y−x)=h^2(c_2-c_1)$

I need some hints on how to prove $c_2-c_1$ is a perfect square which I believe is the only step left; if any of my logic or presentation is wrong, please tell me as well.