Proving that a function is monotone

151 Views Asked by At

Here is the setting: We have a middleman that buys a product from the producers, and sells the product to the customers. The middleman charges a price $R$ to the customers, and pays a price $p(R)$ to buy the product from the producers.

We use $G(R)$ to denote a cumulative density function for a probability distribution, with $G(0)=0$ and $G(\infty)=1$. The $1-G(x)$ distribution represents the customer's willingness to pay for a product, and it is the fraction of consumer that will buy the product if it is priced at $R$.

We know (from other analysis) that the optimal price to pay to the producers of the product $p(R) = R-\frac{1-G(R)}{G'(R)}$. (Assume that the middleman is a monopsonist with the power to set the price of buying.)

Assuming that we are interested only in regions where $p(R)<R$ (i.e., we make a profit when selling) and $p(R)>0$ (i.e., we need to pay a non-zero price to procur the product from the producer), can we prove that the function $p(R)$ does not decrease when we increase the price $R$? In other words, if we increase the price R that we charge customers, can we show that the price that we are willing to pay the supplier also increases?

By setting $\frac{d}{dR}p(R) \geq 0$ we get $G''(R) \geq -2 \cdot \frac{\left(G'(R)\right)^2}{1-G(R)}$

Can we prove that the latter holds, assuming that G(R) can be an arbitrary probability distribution with support in $(0..\infty)$ and that we only care for the regions where $p(R)<R$ and $p(R)>0$? Assume that G'(R) and G''(R) exist, that they are continuous, differentiable, etc.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

OK, it seems that I managed to solve this.

Taking the derivative of p(R) and by setting it to be greater than or equal to 0, we have:

$G′′(R)⋅(1−G(R))≥−2⋅G′(R)⋅G′(R)$

Taking the integral of both sides:

$∫G′′(R)−∫G′′(R)⋅G(R)≥−2∫G′(R)⋅G′(R)$

Taking integration by parts for $∫G′′(R)⋅G(R)$ we have:

$G′(R)−G(R)⋅G′(R)≥−3∫G′(R)⋅G′(R)$

Taking the integral of both sides again:

$G(R)−∫G(R)⋅G′(R)≥−3∫∫G′(R)⋅G′(R)$

We have that ∫G(R)⋅G′(R)=12G(R)2 and this results in:

$G(R)(1−\frac{1}{2}G(R))+3∫∫G′(R)⋅G′(R)≥0$

Since $G(R)≥0$, $1−\frac{1}{2}G(R)≥0.5$ and $G′(R)≥0$, we have a sum of positive terms, which is positive. QED