Quadratic Equation positivity

19 Views Asked by At

$Lemma-4.4.2:$ If $a,b,c$ are real numbers such that $a>0$ and $a\lambda^2+2b\lambda+c\geq0$ for all real number $\lambda$, then $b^2\leq ac$.

This is from "Topics in Algebra by I.N Herstein"

$Question:$ Here in this lemma, if we don't assume $a>0$ then it is still valid. Because $a\lambda^2+2b\lambda+c\geq0$ for all $\lambda$, implies $a>0$.So assuming this extra condition is immaterial. Please correct me.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

2
On

We could also have $a=b=0$, but the conclusion still holds in that case. So the condition is superfluous, but it isn't quite empty because it could possibly not be the case. You could also just as well specify that $a\neq 0$ or $b\neq 0$.

4
On

On the contrary, the condition $a>0$ is necessary. Otherwise, we would not have the quadratic function to be $\ge 0$ identically.