Relatively simple identities that take long to prove

98 Views Asked by At

Can someone give examples of identities, that is, universally quantified equations, that are relatively simple but is very lengthy and/or difficult to prove? I want examples from algebraic structures, not just the standard groups, rings, and fields, but more exotic algebras, like lattices, Boolean algebras, etc. I managed to prove a simple identity myself which required a page of lemmas and algebraic manipulations. That is why I am asking if there are other examples of relatively simple identities which require pages of algebra to prove.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Let $G$ be a finitely generated group of exponent $2^n$ and $a$ be an element in $G$ of order 2, then for every $x\in G$ we have $$[...[x,\underbrace {a],a],...,a]}_{n+1}=1.$$

This identity requires quite a few pages of proof. Even simpler looking formula: if $G$ is a finite $m$-generator group of prime exponent $p$ then the $G$ is nilpotent of class at most

$$\underbrace{m^{m^{...{m}}}}_{3^p}$$

The article by Vaughan-Lee and Zelmanov proving it has about 10 pages but it relies on some heavy results.