Separation of variables and quantum mechanics

337 Views Asked by At

In the book Quantum mechanics by Eugen Merzbacher, third edition, at page 462 he claims that this differential equation (for the unknown operator $F_0=F_0(x,y,z)$) can be solved by separation of variables:

$$[F_0,H_0]|1s\rangle=eEz|1s\rangle,$$

where $H_0$ is the non-relativistic Hamiltonian for the hydrogen atom:

$$H_0=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla^2-\frac{e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{1}{r},$$

$|1s\rangle$ is the fundamental state of the hydrogen atom:

$$|1s\rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi a_0^3}}\exp(-r/a_0),$$

$r=\sqrt{x^2+y^2+z^2}$, $[F_0,H_0]=F_0H_0-H_0F_0$ and the other are constants.

So I tried to use separation of variables $F_0(x,y,z)=X_0(x)Y_0(y)Z_0(z)$, and the equation that I reached is:

$$\frac{X_0Y_0Z_0}{a_0^2r}(r-2a_0)+X_0^{\prime\prime}Y_0Z_0+X_0Y_0^{\prime\prime}Z_0+X_0Y_0Z_0^{\prime\prime}=-\frac{2m}{\hbar^2}eEz$$

and I can't proceed from here, it's different from, for example, the wave equation or the heat equation where you can separate the capital functions on each side of the equation. I also tried $F_0(r,z)=R_0(r)Z_0(z)$, but couldn't proceed too.

My questions are: does this equation can really be solved by separation of variables? If yes, what am I doing wrong? If no, what would you suggest me?

EDIT: The solution given by the author is

$$F_0=-\frac{eEma_0}{\hbar^2}\left( \frac{r}{2}+a_0\right )z$$

One thing that I'm supposing to be true is that, once $F_0$ is a function of the coordinates only, it commutes with any other function of the coordinates only. With this the potential energy term vanish.