symbolic solution to trig equation for a variable

111 Views Asked by At

Is it possible to solve the following singular transcendental equation in $a$ for the variable $a$? Any symbolic solution will do.

$$\sqrt{s^2 - v^2} = 2a \, \sinh \left( \frac{h}{2a} \right)\,\,\,$$

If so, I'd like to see the resulting equation.

Even given additional computation time, Wolfram Alpha can't.

More about the equation on Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catenary#Determining_parameters

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

The inverse of $a\sinh(A/a)=B$ does not possess a closed form expression. Neither does that of the much simpler $a\sinh a=C$, for that matter. However, assuming a very small value for a, we can then easily express the approximate solution in terms of Lambert's W function, since one of the two exponential terms of $\sinh(A/a)$ will be approximately $0$, yielding $\exp(A/a)\approx B/a$, which in its turn gives $a=-A/W(-A/B)$, where $A=h/2$, and $B=\tfrac12\sqrt{s^2-v^2}$. But if a were to be large instead of small, we'd have $\sinh(A/a)\approx A/a+\tfrac16(A/a)^3$, which yields a quadratic equation in a, whose roots are $a=\pm A\Big/\!\sqrt{6~(B/A-1)}$. I'm afraid that, analytically, this is as good as it gets.