The average rainfall is normally distributed. How many times would you expect there to be less than 52 mm of rainfall?

2.3k Views Asked by At

Full question:

The average rainfall of Charlesville in August is normally distributed with mean 68 mm and standard deviation 8 mm. Over a 40 year period, how many times would you expect there to be less than 52 mm of rainfall during August in Charlesville?

I drew a graph of the normal distribution for this data set. Then, finding that $<52$ mm of rain would likely constitute about 2.28% of the data (between $μ-3σ$ and $μ-2σ$), I multiplied $0.0228$ by $40$ to get $0.912$. The textbook answer says that one instance of $<52$ mm of rainfall could be expected over the $40$ year period. Have they just rounded $0.912$ to the nearest whole number, or are they going about it an entirely different way?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

It seems as if you are trying to use the Empirical Rule to solve this problem. According to the ER, about 95% of the probability under a normal curve lies between $\mu \pm 2\sigma.$ Then by symmetry about 2.5% of observations lie below $\mu -2\sigma,$ which is $68 - 2(8) = 52$ for your rainfall distribution. So over a 40-year period, one might expect to see $40(.025) = 1$ year with rainfall that low.

If you know how to use printed tables of the standard normal CDF or to use statistical software, you might get a result that is a bit more accurate:

$$P(X < 52) = P\left(Z = \frac{X - \mu}{\sigma} < \frac{52 - 68}{8}\right) = \cdots,$$

where $Z$ is standard normal, and the procedure of subtracting the mean and then dividing by the standard deviation is called 'standardization'.

In R statistical software standardization (and rounding to use tables) can be avoided:

pnorm(52, 68, 8)
## 0.02275013           # 'about' .025
40*pnorm(52, 68, 8)
## 0.9100053            # 'about' 1

Notes: (1) I share @Did's doubts that $3\sigma$ has anything to do with fining your answer. (2) Also, with your guess that the answerbook is rounding to the nearest integer. (3) This is a fine drill problem, but it has to be an approximation that rainfall is normally distributed. If there is a discrepancy between the model and reality it is likely to be in the far 'tails' of the distribution, which is where your problem is focused.