Two questions about tangent bundles (Resolved)

66 Views Asked by At

We can define the tangent bundle in two ways, depending on how we define our tangent spaces. If our tangent spaces are derivations on the space of smooth germs at $p \in \mathcal M$ (where $\mathcal M$ is a smooth manifold without boundary), then the tangent bundle is $$T\mathcal M := \bigcup_{p\in \mathcal M} T_p\mathcal M$$ since the $T_p\mathcal M$ are already disjoint under this definition. Alternatively, if we define $T_p\mathcal M$ to be the space of derivations at $p$, then $$T\mathcal M := \coprod _{p \in \mathcal M} T_p\mathcal M =\bigcup_{p\in \mathcal M}\{p\}\times T_p\mathcal M.$$ My questions are:

  1. If we define $T_p\mathcal M$ in the second way, how is it that we can say $T\mathcal M$ is a vector bundle with typical fibre $T_p\mathcal M$?
  2. What are the advantages/disadvantages of each definition?