Verification of a proof about the limit of an inner product

63 Views Asked by At

I need some help with the proof I have made. This post is closely related to the attached post but this is a proof verification with some additional questions.

We are given an inner product space $X$ with a sequence $x_n$. We assume that $x_n\rightarrow x$ and $x_n \perp y$, and we want to show that $x\perp y$.

My take:

Since $x_n\perp y$ we know that $(x_n,y)=0$ where $(\;\cdot\;,\;\cdot\;)$ is our inner product. We can write $$ |(x_n,y)-(x,y)|=|(x_n-x,y)|\leq \|x_n-x \|\| y\| $$

We have now a bound on $(x_n,y)-(x,y)$ and since $x_n\rightarrow x$ we can make $\| x_n-x \|$ arbitrarily small, thus also making $(x_n,y)-(x,y)$ arbitrarily small which implies $(x_n,y)=0=(x,y)$ and finally $x\perp y$.

My question is now if this proof is correct. Also, I feel a little uncertain about convergence in inner product spaces. When we work in inner product spaces and say that a sequence convergence (without any additional information), do we mean the "normal" epsilon-delta convergence? Is this the same as strong convergence? This is my first post here, feel free to add comments about how to improve my way of asking questions.

Orthogonality of limits in arbitrary inner product space

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

$x_n \to x$ in an inner product space if the sequence of numbers $\|x_n-x\| \to 0$. What you have done is OK. To give a precise argument you can separate the cases $y=0$ and $y \neq 0$. When $y \neq 0$, given $\epsilon >0$ there exist $n_0$ such that $\|x_n-x\| <\epsilon /||y\|$ for $n >n_0$. This gives $|(x_n,y)-(x,y)| <\epsilon$ for $n >n_0$. This implies $|(x,y)| <\epsilon$. Since $\epsilon $ is arbitrary this gives $(x,y)=0$.