What are the Units of Flux and How do They Relate to Their Physical Meaning

71 Views Asked by At

While taking Calculus III, which included some vector calculus, we defined the flux of a vector field $\mathbf{F} \colon \mathbb{R}^3 \to \mathbb{R}^3$ through a surface $S \subset \mathbb{R}^3$ as $$\iint_S \mathbf{F} \cdot \mathbf{n} \, d\sigma.$$ We were told that if we thought of $\mathbf{F}$ as the vector field defining how a fluid moves through space, the flux calculates the rate at which this fluid flows through $S$. Intuitively then, wouldn't the "units" then be something along the line of $$\frac{``\text{quantity"}}{\text{time}}.$$ So something like "The flux through $S$ is the amount of quantity that moves through it, as defined by $\mathbf{F}$, each unit of time."

However, looking at the integral, the units seem to be different. They seem to be $$\frac{``\text{quantity"}}{\text{time}} \cdot \text{area}.$$ I really don't understand what the extra area quantity is doing. If we want to know the rate at which a quantity moves through $S$, doesn't this imply that $$\frac{``\text{quantity"}}{\text{time}}$$ measures the rate at which a quantity moves through $S$ per unit of area? As if there lies in a secret dimension? Multiplying by area then gives the total flux for that small surface.

Take for example finding the flux of an electric field through a surface. The units of electric flux is $$\frac{\text{N}}{\text{C}} \cdot \text{m}^2.$$ (More surprising here is that there isn't a notion of time; but I suppose that's because previously, we thought of the vector field defining motion?) What is the extra $\text{m}^2$ factor representing? Why wouldn't the total amount of "electric field going through a surface" simply be in the units of the electric field ($\text{N}/\text{C}$) rather than including an extra "area" dimension?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

The thing you integrate is actually flux density, which is a vector (or, rather, a 1-form) and has (if you ignore the fact that it is a linear form and not scalar) units $$\frac{\text{quantity}}{\text{time} \cdot \text{area}}$$ It measures the amount of quantity transported through a unit area oriented in a given direction per unit time. So when you integrate it, you sum over elementary oriented areas (act with this 1-form on the normal vector of element of the surface), and the area cancels out, leaving you with $\text{quantity}/\text{time}$.