What is the discounted (4%) difference in health outcomes between Treatment A and Treatment B using ICER, QALY and utility value?

20 Views Asked by At

I'm studying health economics and have been racking my brain trying to find the right answer to this problem, but I keep getting it wrong no matter what I do. I haven't had any trouble calculating ICER, QALY and DALY until now and none of my textbooks have examples that include discounting the costs and effects. Hopefully someone here can help before I give up.

Formula used:

ICER formula

There are two different treatmeants for a health injury that take place over two years:

  1. Treatment A: Takes place over two years, has costs and effects in both years of the treatment.
  2. Treatment B: Takes place in the first year and therefore only has costs in the first year, but this treatmeant has effects in the year after the intervention.

Costs of treatments

Treatment A:

1st year: 10 400 dollars

2nd year: 10 000 dollars (with a discount of 4 % applied).

Treatment B:

1st year: 28 000 dollars

2nd year: 0 dollars

Saved costs: the health injury costs 8000 dollars in the first year after the injury.

Utility value/health outcome in QALY: 0,55 in the first year after the injury.

The effects of the treatments:

Treatment A: 2 injuries avoided every year

Treatment B: 3 injuries avoided in the 1st year, and 2 injuries avoided in the 2nd year.

A discount of 4 % has to be applied to all costs and health outcomes/effects, but only to the the second year, not the first year. This is one of the issues I'm having. I don't know which numbers to apply the discount to. I also can't figure out how much is saved in costs by preventing injury.