What is the time in the afternoon problem

122 Views Asked by At

I have been reading Ray's Intellectual Arithmetic and I stumbled upon the following problem:

What is the time in the afternoon, when the time past noon is equal to $1/5$ of the time past midnight?

The solution goes like this:

Let $5/5$ be the whole time. The time past noon is $1/5$. From midnight to noon is $4/5$. Then $4/5 = 12$. Therefore $1/5$ is $3$ o'clock in the afternoon.

But $4$ o'clock is also $1/5$ of some time after midnight. Is this problem ambiguous?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

I interpret the question as currently the time is $x$.

Noon is the time corresponding to $12:00$ hours and midnight is the time corresponding to $00:00$ hours

The time past noon is $x-12$ and the time past midnight is $x-0$.

$$x-12 = \frac15 ( x-0)$$

$$\frac{4x}5=12$$

$$x=15$$

That is $x$ is $15:00$ hours, which corresponds to $3pm$.

Remark about $4$ O' clock is some times after midnight. Let that time be $

$$16-12=\frac15(16-y)$$

$$y=-4$$

There is no time after midnight that make the equation holds unless you are measuring from $8pm$ the previous day.