When to use AND and when to use OR when we are solving a problem assosiated with absolute value?

42 Views Asked by At

What are the values of $n$ that satisfy the condition $1/|n| > n$?

(a) $0<n<1$ (and) $ -\infty < n < 0$

(b) $0 < n < \infty$ (or) $-\infty < n < -1$

(c) $0 < n < 1$ (and) $-1 < n < 0$

(d) $-\infty < n < 0$ (or) $0 < n < 1$

(e) $0<n<1$ (or) $-\infty < n < 0$

My problem is not: why the answer is option-a. My question is why we should choose an option that has AND.

To me, option e is correct. In option e, we find OR instead of AND. Option e seems correct to me because $0<n<1$ alone can satisfy the $1/|n| > n$. And $-\infty<n<0$ alone can satisfy the condition as well. To me AND seems appropriate when neither $0<n<1$ nor $-\infty<n<0$ alone can satisfy the condition. If in order to satisfy the condition, both must be applied at a time, only then usage of AND seems correct to me.

The fact why AND are appropriate here was discussed in the site from which I have collected this question. But their explanations don't make any sense to me. I cannot understand their explanation.

Another question is: what are the differences between option d and option e?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

The question asks us to consider the set $A =\{n:\frac{1}{|n|} > n\}$. It would have been helpful for the question to state that $n \neq 0$ but we will assume this.

By considering the cases $n>0$ (which leads to $n^2 < 1$ so $0 < n < 1$) and $n<0$ (which leads to $n^2 > -1$ which is true for all $n$), we can see that:

$A = B \cup C$ where $B=\{n: 0 < n <1 \}$ and $C=\{n:n < 0 \}$

It seems slightly odd to write "$-\infty < n < 0$". If we are assuming $n$ is real that is normally just written $n <0$.

Set $A$ is made up of set $B$ and set $C$. So, to consider the options:

The values that $n$ can take are those in set $B$ and in set $C$. So that is option (a).

If the question had said "what is the possible value of $n$" then we would say

$n \in B \cup C$ so $n \in B$ or $n \in C$, and (e) would be the better option.

But I feel it's a bit of nit-picking distinction!