Why $D_4$ is the biggest group generated by relations $\langle f,r | f^2 =1 ,r^4 =1 , fr=r^3f \rangle$?

58 Views Asked by At

I want to find the presentation of group $D_4= \{1, f, r,r^2,r^3, rf, r^2f, r^3f \} $. $r$ is the rotation of a square counterclockwise by 90 degree and $f$ is the action that flips the square. Here $f$ has order $2$ and $r$ has order $4$. enter image description here

I have found that the relations $$f^2 =1 \\ r^4 =1 \\ fr=r^3f$$ can deduce all the operation results of elements in $D_4$. However, I am not sure $D_4 =\langle f,r | f^2 =1 ,r^4 =1 , fr=r^3f \rangle $ is the presentation of $D_4$. In other words, is $D_4$ the biggest group having these relations?

I feel that equality is key to this question. One must show there are no other equalities of two elements except those deduced from the abovementioned generating relations.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

The usual reasoning is this.

Hints.

Let $F=\operatorname{gr}(x,y)$ be a free group with free generators $x$ and $y$, and $H$ be a normal subgroup generated by $x^2$, $y^4$, and $(xy)^2$.

  1. Consider the homomorphism $\phi:F\to D_4$ defined by the formulas $\phi(x)=f$, $f(y)=r$. Clearly, $H\leq\operatorname{Ker}(\phi)$ and $\operatorname{Im}(\phi)=D_4$. Therefore the factor-group $|F/H|\geq |D_4|$

  2. Let us prove that $|F/H|\leq8$. To do this, work with words in the group $F$. Using the fact that $x^2,y^4,(xy)^2\in H$ we prove that $$ x^{k_1}y^{l_1}\ldots x^{k_s}y^{l_s}H=x^ky^lH, $$ where $k_i,l_i,k,l\in\mathbb{Z}$ and $0\leq k<2$, $0\leq l<4$.

  3. It follows from 1 and 2 that $F/H\cong D_4$.