why is my expectation of where the critical points are disagreeing with my graph?

46 Views Asked by At

given the parametrised function

$$f_t(x,y,z)=z^3+tz-x^2+y^2$$

We know that that the gradient vector field is

$\nabla f_t=(-2x,2y,3z^2+t)$

Now I originally thought that the critical points were at $(0,0,\sqrt{\tfrac{-t}{3}})$. but when I graphed the level sets of the functions for t=0,1,-1. It seemed as though critical points happened at $(0,0,0), (0,0,\sqrt{\tfrac{1}{3}})(0,0,-\sqrt{\tfrac{1}{3}})$

where am i going wrong ?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

Note that

$$t=1 \implies 3z^2+t >0 \quad \forall z$$

therefore we can't have a critical point for that value of the parameter $t$, more in general we need $t \le 0$ as a necessary condition to have critical points.