Why is the addition of two vectors and the resultant of two forces are taken in two different ways?

675 Views Asked by At

The sum of two vectors for example $\vec{P}$ and $\vec{Q}$ are taken as $\vec{P}+\vec{Q}$ but when we take the resultant of two non parallel forces $\vec{P}$ and $\vec{Q}$, we take it as

$$R^2 =P^2+ Q^2+ 2PQ \cos \theta$$

Why is that? Why can't we take the resultant of the two forces in the same manner we do in Vectors? As Force is a vector quantity?

A simple explanation(that is without heavy technical terms) would be preferred)
2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On

you're talking of $\left |R^2 \right |$ so you are talking of $\left \| P+Q \right \|^2$. You know that $\left \| v \right \| is \sqrt{\left \langle v.v\right \rangle}$, so $\left \| P+Q \right \|^2=\left \langle P+Q.P+Q\right \rangle$ but the inner product is bilinear so $\left \| P+Q \right \|^2=\left \| P \right \|^2+\left \|Q \right \|^2+2\left \langle P.Q\right \rangle$ where $2\left \langle P,Q\right \rangle$ is $2PQcos\theta$.

I hope I didn't do any mistake.

0
On

I think you are a bit confused.

The addition of two vectors (any vectors) is always done element by element

$$\mathbf{R} = \mathbf{P} + \mathbf{Q} = \pmatrix{P_x \\ P_y \\ P_z} + \pmatrix{Q_x\\Q_y\\Q_z} = \pmatrix{ P_x+Q_x \\ P_y+Q_y \\ P_z+Q_z}= \pmatrix{R_x \\ R_y \\ R_z} $$

and the magnitude of a vector is always defined by the Euclidean norm

$$ R = \| \mathbf{R} \| = \| \pmatrix{R_x \\ R_y \\ R_z} \| = \sqrt{R_x^2+R_y^2+R_z^2} $$

The formula that you state is the cosine rule and you can derive it by taking the magnitude of the addition of two vectors. One with magnitude $P$ along the $x$-axis and one with magnitude $Q$ at an angle $\theta$ from the $x$-axis.

$$\begin{aligned} \mathbf{P} & = \pmatrix{P \\ 0} \\ \mathbf{Q} & = \pmatrix{Q \cos\theta \\ Q \sin \theta} \end{aligned}$$

$$ R = \| \mathbf{P} + \mathbf{Q} \| = \sqrt{ (P+Q \cos\theta)^2 + (Q \sin\theta)^2 } = \sqrt{P^2+Q^2+2 P Q \cos\theta} $$

NOTE: Vector quantities are bold (as in $\mathbf{P}$) and scalars are not (as in $P$).