Why is the index of the stabilizer neccesarily greater than 1?

253 Views Asked by At

I am currently self-studying Aluffi's Algebra book at chapter IV on on Group actions in which he gives the counting formula where $G$ is a group that acts on a finite set $S$ being:

$$\lvert S \rvert = \lvert Z \rvert + \sum_{a \in A} [G: G_a],$$

where $Z$ is the set of fixed point under the action and $A \subseteq S$ contains exactly one element for each nontrivial orbit of the action and $G_a$ is the stabilizer of $a$.

He claimed that each $[G:G_a]$ is a divisor of $\mid G \mid$ and also each $[G:G_a] > 1$ in which I understand the divisor part since it is equal to the cardinality of the orbit of $a$ and orbits partion the set, but I just don't get why $[G:G_a] > 1$ since isn't $1$ is a divisor for every integers?

Since I am self-studying, any information would be helpful.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

If $[G:G_a] = 1$, then $G = G_a$ which would mean that $a$ is fixed by the group action and hence $a \in Z$ and hence $a \notin A$ since it would have a trivial orbit.

0
On

This follows from the definition of the set $A$. If $a\in A$ then $a$ belongs to a nontrivial orbit. So there must be some element $g\in G$ such that $g.a\ne a$. Hence $G_a\ne G$.