Why would vector space addition axiom #5 be verified in this way?

368 Views Asked by At

Given V = $\mathbb{R}$ with the following addition and scalar multiplication: $$x+y = x+y+7$$ $$a \cdot x=ax+7(a-1)$$ where a $\in \mathbb{R}$, while proving that V is a vector space, how come the correct way to verify axiom #5* is as follows:
$$x+y=7$$ $$x+y+7=-7$$ $$x+y=-14$$ $$y=-14-x$$ and not: $$x+y+7=0$$ $$y=-x-7$$

Since the axiom states that $u+(-u)=0$ then why would $x+y=7$ and not $x+y=0$

* Axiom #5 states that for each u in V, there exists another vector "-u" such that $u+(-u)=(-u)+u=0$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

I'm going to use $\oplus$ for vector addition. The zero vector is $-7$, since for all $x$ we have

$$x \oplus -7 = x + (-7) + 7 = x.$$

So, to find the inverse of any $x$, we need a $y$ such that $x \oplus y = -7$:

$$x \oplus y = -7\\ x + y + 7 =-7\\ y = -x - 14$$

Without distinguishing $+$ from $\oplus$, this would get very confusing! How is it actually written in your notes (or textbook), I wonder?