Willard's very extreme example of topological space

79 Views Asked by At

In Willard's General Topology, page 32, he says:

"If $y$ is close to $x$ in a metric space, then $x$ is close to $y$; but it can happen in a topological space that $y$ is in every neighborhood of $x$ while $x$ is in no neighborhood of $y$ (a very extreme example; this doesn't happen in useful topological spaces, although many useful spaces lack symmetry in some degree)"

But I do not get how could this be possible. How can such extreme example of topological space exist if the whole space contains itself and then it is a neighborhood of any point, so there cannot be a point that is in no neighborhood of the other?

Any clarification on what he meant would be accepted, or even an explicit example of such very extreme topological space.

Thanks.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

You are correct: the entire space will always be a neighborhood of $y$ which contains $x$. (I'm assuming $x \neq y$.) I'm guessing he wanted to exclude that neighborhood as a trivial example, and to say that no other neighborhoods of $y$ contain $x$.

In the Sierpiński space, for example, $1$ has a neighborhood that does not contain $0$, but $0$ has a single neighborhood, which does contain $1$. More generally, the "excluded point topology" will give you more examples.