$|2\sin^2 x-1|>\cos x$: graphic and analytical method resolution

118 Views Asked by At

I have this inequality

$$|2\sin^2 x-1|>\cos x \iff |\cos(2x)|>\cos x \tag 1$$

or equivalently to

$$|1-2\cos^2x|>\cos x \tag 2$$

To solve the $(2)$ is trivial by taking it to an absolute value inequality of the second degree, but it would waste a lot of time, at least in my opinion. I did this exercise this morning to my 17 year old high school students using the graphical method with the $(1)$.

First I hand drew everything keeping in mind that the principal period $T=\pi$ for $\cos(2x)$. My graph it was correct and it is similar to this done with Geogebra:

enter image description here

I have said that all the solutions are just that between the $y$-value point of $A$ and the $y$-value point of $B$. Being $A\equiv(\ldots; 0.5)$ and $B\equiv(\ldots; 0.5)$ we have that the angles $x$ are, $\pi/3$ and $2\pi-\pi/3$.

For my students, to speed up the calculations, without the use of Geogebra how is it possible to find the coordinates of points $A$ and $B$ using the scientific calculator or some simple method other than numerical methods, derivatives, series expansion, etc.?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

Notice that the intersections are solutions of

$$\cos(2x)=\pm\cos(x),$$

hence

$$2x=\pm x+2k\pi$$ or $$2x=\pm x+(2k+1)\pi.$$

Finally,

$$x=\frac{k\pi}3.$$

The rest is a matter of sign discussion.

0
On

I include my answer...

Remark: In $\Bbb R$, $|a|=b\iff (b\ge0\wedge(a=\pm b))$.

For this remark we have:

$$\cos(2x)=|\cos(x)|\iff(\cos(2x)\ge0)\wedge((\cos x=\cos(2x))\vee(\cos x=-\cos(2x)).$$

  • The equation $\cos(2x)=+ \cos (x) \iff \cos(2x)-\cos (x)=0$ not give me any solution for to find $A$ and $B$, but

$$\cos(2x)+\cos (x)=2\cos\left(\frac{3x}{2}\right)\cos\left(\frac{x}{2}\right)=0.$$ For the

$$\cos \left(\frac{3x}{2}\right)=0$$ I will have

$$x=\frac{\pi}3+\frac{4}3k\pi, \quad x=\pi+\frac{4}3k\pi \tag 1$$

For the $$\cos \left(\frac{x}{2}\right)=0$$ I will have

$$x=3\pi+4k\pi, \quad x=\pi+4k\pi \tag 2$$

Merge overlapping the intervals $(1)$ and $(2)$ I will have

$$x=\frac{\pi }{3}+\frac{4\pi k}{3},\:x=\pi +\frac{4\pi k}{3}$$

and the accepted solutions are only

$$x=\frac{\pi }{3}+\frac{4\pi k}{3}$$