A planar cut through an oblique cone

150 Views Asked by At

An oblique cone has a circular base centered at the origin of radius $5$, and an apex at $(0, 5, 20)$. A plane whose equation is $3x-4y+5z = 40$ cuts through the oblique cone, and the resulting cut is an ellipse. Find the equation of the ellipse in the form:

$ P(t) = C + w_1 \cos t + w_2 \sin t $

where $C$ is the center and $w_1$ and $w_2$ are the vectors specifying the semi-minor and semi-major axes of the ellipse.

My Attempt:

My attempt is incomplete, but the basic idea I am following is to parameterize the plane, as follows,

$ r = r_0 + V u $

and then plug this into the equation of the cone, which I don't have.

So I still have to find a way to find the algebraic (implicit) equation of the cone. And from there, it should be straight forward to write a quadratic form in $u$ which will give the two axes of the cut ellipse.

Any hints, comments or solutions are highly appreciated.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

One way to get the equation of the oblique cone is to use a linear transformation that would map the oblique cone to a right cone, then use the equation for the right cone. I will use the following claims.

Claim 1: The image of the cone under the shear transformation $T:\Bbb R^3 \to \Bbb R^3$ given by $$ T\pmatrix{x\\y\\z} = \pmatrix{x\\y-\frac 14 z\\ z} $$ is a right cone.

Claim 2: The right cone that is obtained by the transformation $T$ above has equation $$ z = 20 - 4 \sqrt{x^2 + y^2}. $$

Given the above two claims, it follows that the equation of the oblique cone is given by $$ z = 20 - 4\sqrt{x^2 + (y - \tfrac 14 z)^2}. $$ From there, it suffices to parameterize the plane in the form $r(u,v) = r_0 + uw_1 + vw_2$ for suitable vectors $w_1,w_2$.


Outline of solution to rest of the problem:

To begin, we find a parameterization of the plane. First, we find an orthonormal basis with which to parameterize the plane. The plane is orthogonal to the vector $(3,-4,5)$. One vector orthogonal to this is $(4,3,0)$. An orthogonal direction to this within the plane can be found using the cross-product $$ (3,-4,5) \times (4,3,0) = (-15,20,25). $$ Normalizing these, we find that the vectors $v_1 = \frac 15(4,3,0)$ and $v_2 = \frac 1{5\sqrt{2}}(-3,4,5)$ form an orthogonal basis of the plane $(3,-4,5)^\perp$. One reference point on the plane of interest is given by setting $x = y = 0$ to get the point $(0,0,8)$. Thus, we have the following parameterization of the plane: $$ \mathbf r(s,t) = (0,0,8) + sv_1 + tv_2. $$ Notably, the map from $(s,t)$ to $\mathbf r(s,t)$ is an isometric embedding of $\Bbb R^2$. Thus, an ellipse within the plane corresponds to the "same" ellipse within $\Bbb R^2$.

Plugging $\mathbf r(s,t)$ into the equation for the cone, namely $$ 16x^2 + 16(y - \tfrac 14 z)^2 - (z - 20)^2 = 0 $$ yields $$ 16 s^{2} - \frac{12 \sqrt{2} s t}{5} + \frac{24 t^{2}}{5} - \frac{192 s}{5} - \frac{28 \sqrt{2} t}{5} = 80 $$ Now, denote $$ A = \pmatrix{16 & - \frac{6 \sqrt{2}}{5}\\- \frac{6 \sqrt{2}}{5} & \frac{24}{5}}, \quad b = \pmatrix{\frac{192}{5}\\\frac{28 \sqrt{2}}{5}},\quad c = \pmatrix{\frac{103}{77}\\ \frac{212 \sqrt{2}}{231}}, \quad \mathbf x = \pmatrix{s\\t}. $$ we can write the equation over $s$ and $t$ in the form $$ \mathbf x^TA \mathbf x + b^T \mathbf x - 80 = 0 $$ and, after computing $c = -\frac 12 A^{-1}b$, write this in the form $$ (\mathbf x - c)^TA(\mathbf x - c) = \frac{25600}{231} \implies\\ (\mathbf x - c)^TM(\mathbf x - c) =1, $$ where $M = \frac{231}{25600} A$. Conclude that within $\Bbb R^2$, the ellipse with the above equation has center $c$. The lengths of the major and minor axes are the reciprocals of the smaller and larger eigenvalues of $M$ (respectively), and the vectors corresponding to these axes are the associated eigenvectors. We can parameterize this ellipse with the equation $$ \pmatrix{s\\t} = \mathbf x = r + \lambda_1^{-1} \cos \tau \,u_1 + \lambda_2^{-1} \sin \tau \,u_2, $$ where $\lambda_1 > \lambda_2$ are the eigenvalues of $M$ and $u_1,u_2$ the associated eigenvectors. Plugging in the resulting formula for $s$ and $t$ into $\mathbf r(s,t)$ will yield the desired parameterization.

0
On

Here's a handy alternative to the method that uses a transformation of a right cone. It comes from Salmon, The Analytic Geometry of Three Dimensions (1865), pg 83, Ex 7

The equation of the cone whose apex is $(x',y',z')$ and whose base is the conic $\dfrac{x^2}{a^2}+\dfrac{y^2}{b^2}=1$ is $$ \dfrac{(z'x-x'z)^2}{a^2}+\dfrac{(z'y-y'z)^2}{b^2}=(z'-z)^2. $$

This gives the equation $2x^2+2y^2-yz+5z=50$ for the cone in question.