Are maximal ideals and principal ideals independent?

33 Views Asked by At

How can I show that the properties maximal and principal can be true independently for an ideal?

I can find one example of each:

  1. A maximal principal ideal
  2. A maximal non-principal ideal
  3. A non-maximal principal ideal
  4. A non-maximal non-principal ideal

Is there a shortcut?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

I think the easiest examples come from algebraic geometry.

An example of a principal ideal that is maximal is given by $\langle x\rangle \subset k[x]$, which corresponds to the zero point in $\mathbb{A}_k$ and thus is maximal.

An example of a principal non maximal ideal is given by $\langle 0\rangle\subset \mathbb{Z}$.

For a maximal non principal ideal take $\langle x,y\rangle \subset k[x,y]$.

For something that is neither maximal nor principal, take the vanishing of two polynomials which does not consist of only one point.