calculating the stream function

119 Views Asked by At

Given that the flow is found incompressible (previous question here), is the approach above the right way towards finding the stream function? given that: $\mathbf{u}=\sin{x}\sin{y}\mathbf{i}+\cos{x}\cos{y}\mathbf{j}$

$$\tag{B} \sin{x}\sin{y}=\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial y}\qquad \cos{x}\cos{y}=-\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial x}$$

I have thought of approaching it this way:

$\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial y}=\sin{x}\sin{y} = \int\sin{x}\sin{y}$ and integrating with respect to y:

  1. $-\cos{y}\sin{x} + f(x)$ where f(x) is a constant of integration, and substituting the second part of (B).
  2. $\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial x}(-\cos{y}\sin{x} + f(x)) = -f'(x) ; f(x) =-\sin{x}\cos{y} + C $
  3. Therefore when adding both integrated factors we get : $\phi=-\cos{y}\sin{x}-\sin{x}\cos{y}$ where $\phi$ is a constant.

Which is equal to: $-2\cos{y}\sin{x}?$ when we simplify the equation on the right-side on 3.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Step one gives you

$$ \phi(x,y) = -\cos y\sin x+f(x)$$ for some $f(x)$, and step two gives $$ \phi(x,y) = -\cos y\sin x+g(y),$$ for some $g(y)$. These are both correct.

It does not follow that $\phi$ is constant, i.e. your step 3 is wrong. Instead, combine the first two steps, and you should see $f\equiv0\equiv g$. (get some paper and actually write it out carefully, if it is not clear.)

You can check by direct computation that your guess for $\phi$ is wrong: Well, firstly, $\phi$ is not a constant, and neither is $-2\cos y \sin x$, but if you meant to say that

$$\phi(x,y)=-2\cos y \sin x$$

then just differentiate in either $x$ or $y$ to see that you have an extra factor of $2$.