Calculus of variations when target space has boundary

66 Views Asked by At

Let $M,N$ be smooth oriented Riemannian manifolds; $M$ closed and $N$ with non-empty boundary. Let $f:M \to N$ be smooth and suppose the image of $f$ intersects $\partial N$.

Let $$W:=\{V \in \Gamma(f^*TN)\, | \, \text{There exist a variation }\, f_t \text{ with variation field } V \}.$$

(By a variation we mean a smooth family $f_t$, such that $f_0=f,\frac{\partial f_t}{\partial t}|_{t=0}=V$).

Question:

Let $A \in \Gamma(f^*TN)$ and suppose $\langle A,V \rangle=0$ for every $V \in W$. Is it true that $A=0$?

(The inner product $\langle A,V \rangle$ is the integral product of sections of $f^*TN$ induced by the metrics on $M,N$).

The point is that $W$ is constrained, it is a strict subset of $\Gamma(f^*TN)$: For every $p \in M$, such that $f(p) \in \partial N$, $V(p)$ must be tangent to $\partial N$ or "inward-pointing" (it cannot point outside). This is clearly a necessary condition for a variation to exist.

A subquestion: Is this condition sufficient for the existence of a variation?

Since $W \subsetneq \Gamma(f^*TN)$ we cannot use directly the density of the smooth sections to conclude $A=0$.


Of course, the motivation is calculus of variations. If there is some reference which treats this issue I would be happy to know.