Checking some work on finding roots

37 Views Asked by At

OK, I have the following response function:

$$H(\omega) = \frac{1-\omega^2 LC}{1+\omega^2 LC - i \omega RC}$$

I want to find where it becomes $\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}$.

This should be simple enough. First I multiply the whole thing by its complex conjugate, which gives me the absolute value squared, or 1/2:

$$\frac{1-\omega^2 LC}{1+\omega^2 LC - i \omega RC}=\frac{(1-\omega^2 LC)^2}{(1+\omega^2 LC)^2 + \omega^2 R^2C^2} = \frac{1}{2}$$

Then I want to solve for omega. Since this is kind of ugly as it is I multiply both sides by $2((1+\omega^2 LC)^2 + \omega^2 R^2C^2)$ and end up with

$$2(1-\omega^2 LC)^2=(1+\omega^2 LC)^2 + \omega^2 R^2C^2$$ which yields

$$(1-\omega^2 LC)^2= \omega^2 R^2C^2$$

which I can take the square roots of both sides and turn it into a quadratic

$$(1-\omega^2 LC)= \omega RC \rightarrow 1-\omega RC - \omega^2LC = 0$$

I pull out the old quadratic formula. $\omega = \frac{RC \pm \sqrt{R^2C^2+4LC}}{2LC}$

On the plus side we end up with $\frac{2R^2C^2 + 2RC\sqrt{R^2C^2+4LC}+4LC}{2LC}=\frac{R^2C}{L}+\frac{R}{L}\sqrt{R^2C^2+4LC}+2$

and on the minus side $\frac{2R^2C^2 - 2RC\sqrt{R^2C^2+4LC}+4LC}{2LC}=\frac{R^2C}{L}-\frac{R}{L}\sqrt{R^2C^2+4LC}+2$

Anther method I thought of was to try and break up the quadratic "by hand" -- that is, try to come up with some square root of the coefficient of omega squared and half of RC, but down that path lieth madness.

OK, seems fine. But I am told that the answer you ought to get is $\omega = \frac{1}{RC}$. So either a) I messed up badly or b) I am being told wrong.

Did I miss something here? This isn't even calculus.

EDIT: looking at where I messed up: OK Seeing as I messed up here:

$$2(1-\omega^2LC)^2 = (1+\omega^2LC)^2 + \omega^2 R^2C^2$$

That really ought to be

$$(2 - 4\omega^2LC + 2\omega^4L^2C^2) = 1 + 2\omega^2LC + \omega^4L^2C^2+ \omega^2 R^2C^2$$

Which then becomes

$$(1 - 6\omega^2LC + \omega^4L^2C^2) = \omega^2 R^2C^2$$ turning that into something like a quadratic

$$1+(6LC-R^2C^2)\omega^2+ \omega^4L^2C^2=0$$

(and substituting $u$ for $\omega^2$ means the LHS reduces to $ (1+(6LC-R^2C^2)u + L^2C^2u^2)$

We hit it with the quadratic formula. $$\frac{R^2C^2-6LC \pm \sqrt{36L^2C^2-12R^2LC^3+R^4C^4-4L^2C^2}}{2L^2C^2}=\frac{R^2C^2-6LC \pm \sqrt{32L^2C^2-12R^2LC^3+R^4C^4}}{2L^2C^2}=\frac{R^2}{2L^2}-\frac{3}{L}\pm \frac{\sqrt{32L^2-12R^2LC+R^4C^2}}{2L^2C}$$

Still getting crazy numbers.... hmmm.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

You messed up at least once, in this step:

$$2(1-\omega^2 LC)^2=(1+\omega^2 LC)^2 + \omega^2 R^2C^2$$ which yields

$$(1-\omega^2 LC)^2= \omega^2 R^2C^2$$