Cocompact group actions have cobounded orbits

746 Views Asked by At

Assume $X$ is a complete, locally compact, geodesic metric space (in particular, $X$ has closed balls are compact, by the Hopf-Rinow Theorem). Assume $G$ acts isometrically on $X$. We say $Q\subset X$ is cobounded if there is $r\ge 0$ such that for every $y\in X$, there is some $q\in Q$ such that $d(y,q) \le r$.

I am trying to prove that the quotient space $X/G$ is compact if and only if every orbit of $G$ is cobounded in $X$.

I'd very much appreciate if someone could let me know whether or not the following is valid. In particular, page 19 of https://www.math.ucdavis.edu/~kapovich/280-2009/bhb-ggtcourse.pdf suggests that I need the additional assumption that the action of $G$ is properly discontinuous. However, my proof did not use this fact.

Proof (?):

(1) $\to$ (2): We may give $X/G$ a metric. Define $$d_{Q} (G\cdot x, G\cdot y) = \min\{d(x, g\cdot y) : g\in G\}$$

It is straightforward to check this metric induces the quotient topology. Choose some orbit $G\cdot x \in X/G$. There is $r$ such that $X/G \subset N(G\cdot x, r)$. For any $y\in X$, it follows $d_{Q} (G\cdot y, G\cdot x) \le r$, hence $d(y, g\cdot x) \le r$ for some $g\in G$. Thus $G\cdot x$ is cobounded.

(2) $\to$ (1): Again, choose $G\cdot x \in X/G$. Assume $G\cdot x$ is $r$-dense in $X$. Then, for any $y\in X$, there is $g\in G$ such that $d(x,g\cdot y) \le r$. By Hopf-Rinow, we know $N(x, r)$ is compact. The projection map $q: X \to X/G$ given by $x \mapsto G\cdot x$ is continuous. Hence $q(N(x,r)) = X/G$ is compact.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

3
On

You may not give any old crummy space like $X/G$ a metric. Maybe it's not even Hausdorff. Take for example the additive action of $\mathbb{Q}$ on $\mathbb{R}$.

0
On

It suffices to assume that X is a proper metric space; no need to assume that it is geodesic and that the group action is isometric and proper. Fix a point $x\in X$ and define open $i$-balls $B(x,i)$ in X. Projecting these balls to $K=X/G$ will define an open cover. By compactness of K, one of these balls will cover K. Now, take its closure.