Completeness of the metric r(x,y)=min{d(x,y},1}

842 Views Asked by At

Can somebody help me out with the following:

If (X,d) is a metric space and r(x,y)=min{d(x,y},1} for all x,y in X. I proved that r is a metric and that r and d are equivalent. Now I want to prove that (X,r) is complete if and only if (X,d) is complete.

This was my idea: Suppose {xn} is a Cauchy sequence in X, then {xn} is r-convergent in X (completeness). Because of the equivalence of r and d, {xn} is also d-convergent and thus (X,d) is complete. The other way is the same. Can somebody say if this is correct?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

13
On

Your idea doesn't quite work. Topological equivalence is agnostic to distances, which are used to define the notion of a Cauchy sequence. For example, we can endow $\Bbb{R\setminus Q}$ with a complete metric which is equivalent to the standard metric, which is far from being complete.

HINT: Recall that in the definition of a Cauchy sequence we care more about small $\varepsilon$ than about large $\varepsilon$.

In particular, what happens when we consider $\varepsilon<1$? How do the metrics $r$ and $d$ differ in that case?