Deriving small angle approximation $ \cos\delta_a\cos\delta_b\ \approx \cos^2\delta_a $

54 Views Asked by At

I'm trying to understand the derivation for the small angular distance approximation formula for the Angular Distance, as explained in Wikipedia

Almost to the end of the derivation, I'm presented with a small angle approximation I can't make sense of:

Given that $ \delta_a - \delta_b \ll 1 $ and $ \alpha_a - \alpha_b \ll 1 $, at a second-order development it turns that

$$ \cos\delta_a\cos\delta_b\frac{(\alpha_a-\alpha_b)^2}{2} \approx \cos^2\delta_a\frac{(\alpha_a-\alpha_b)^2}{2} $$

This seems to imply that:

$$ \cos\delta_a\cos\delta_b\ \approx \cos^2\delta_a $$

How did they get this approximation?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

We can expand things out using a standard "sum of angle" formula:

$$\begin{eqnarray} \cos \delta_b & = & \cos (\delta_b - \delta_a + \delta_a) \\ & = & \cos (\delta_b - \delta_a) \cos \delta_a - \sin (\delta_b - \delta_a) \sin \delta_a \\ & = & \cos(\delta_a - \delta_b) \cos \delta_a + \sin(\delta_a - \delta_b) \sin \delta_a \end{eqnarray}$$

Now, if $\delta_a - \delta_b \ll 1$, then $\cos(\delta_a - \delta_b) \approx 1$ and $\sin(\delta_a - \delta_b) \approx 0$, which reduces the above to $\cos \delta_b \approx \cos \delta_a$.

To use your example values from the comments, if $\delta_a = 0.0009$ and $\delta_b = 0.000009$, we have $\cos \delta_a \approx 0.9999999998766$ and $\cos \delta_b \approx 0.99999999999998766$, so the difference between the two is about $1.2 \times 10^{-10}$. Notice that this mostly comes about because both angles are so small that in both cases $\cos \delta \approx 1$ is already a reasonable approximation.