Difficulties with an elliptic integral (Ahlfors)

260 Views Asked by At

In Ahlfors' Complex Analysis text, page 239 he defines $$F(w)=\int_0^w \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}} $$ where $0<k<1$ is a constant.

He notes

this time we agree that $\sqrt{1-w^2}$and $\sqrt{1-k^2w^2}$ shall have positive real parts.

Exercise 1 asks us to show that $$F(\infty)=\int_0^\infty \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}=iK' $$ where $K'=\int_1^{1/k} \frac{dt}{\sqrt{(t^2-1)(1-k^2t^2)}}.$

I have two questions:

  1. Can we really determine the square roots by the sign of their real parts, as the author claims? (given that $w$ lies in the closed upper half plane).

  2. What's wrong with my evaluation below of $F(\infty)$?

I'm asking 1 because taking $w=bi$ with $b>1$, makes the expression $1-w^2$ negative, hence it's real part is zero.

As for the evaluation of the integral, we have

$$\int_0^\infty \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}=\int_0^1 \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}+\int_1^{1/k} \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}+\int_{1/k}^\infty \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}. $$ The middle integral in the RHS clearly equals $iK'$, and it will suffice to show that the other two cancel each other out. Well, I only found that

$$\int_{1/k}^\infty \frac{dw}{\sqrt{(1-w^2)(1-k^2w^2)}}=\int_{0}^1 \frac{dt}{\sqrt{(1-t^2)(1-k^2t^2)}}, $$ using the substitution $t=\frac{1}{kw}$. I believe I'm missing a minus sign here?

Help is greatly appreciated!

EDIT:

I should have written "$w=b$ with $b>1$" above.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER
  1. The square roots must give continuous functions on their whole domain. (They must be analytic in the interior, but are only continuous at some boundary points.) This determines $\sqrt{1-w^2}$ when $w = bi$ and $b > 1$ as being on the upper imaginary axis near the function value for $w = \epsilon+bi$.

  2. The square roots must be taken for each factor ${1-w^2}$ and ${1-k^2w^2}$ separately, since otherwise it is too unclear how to choose the sign of the square root of the product so as to make the function even continuous. For $1/k < w < \infty$, the individual square roots are on the upper imaginary axis so their product is negative. Your sign error is from taking the square root of the product.

$w = bi$ confused me too. The following corrections are needed to my answer:

1a. The boundary is the entire real axis, and there is a sign ambiguity at every point of the boundary. This is resolved by requiring continuity.

2a. For $1/k < w < \infty$, the individual square roots are actually on the lower imaginary axis. Their product is still negative. However, for the subinterals between the cusps $\{\pm1, \pm k\}$ in which only 1 of the square roots is imaginary, this choice of sign for the square roots is critical -- it is what makes the contour traversed by the integral $F(w)$ go around clockwise as $w$ traverses the real axis from left to right.