Does $A(x, m) = 1 - A(m, x)$ imply some symmetry in partial derivatives?

315 Views Asked by At

This is a self-made problem. I have a function $A$ of variables $x, m \geq 0$. A satisfies the following symmetry:

$$A(x, m) = 1 - A(m, x)$$

Is there an equation that relates the partial derivative of $A$ wrt the first argument to the partial derivative of $A$ with respect to the second argument? It seems like there should be something straightforward but I'm not sure how to deduce it.

Thank you!

3

There are 3 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

All you need to do is differentiate both sides of the symmetry equation-

$$(\partial_1 A)(x,m) = \frac d{dx}[A(x,m)] = \frac d{dx}[1-A(m,x)] = - (\partial_2 A)(m,x)$$

or did you want something more?

1
On

I suggest using the definition of partial derivative to have a clearer point of view on the situation. The partial derivative of $A$ with respect to the first variable at the point $(x_0,m_0)$ is defined by :

$$\partial_1 A(x_0,m_0)=\lim_{h\to0} \frac{A(x_0+h,m_0)-A(x_0,m_0)}{h}.$$

Using the symmetry relation, we have :

$$\lim_{h\to0} \frac{(1-A(m_0,x_0+h))-(1-A(m_0,x_0))}{h}=\lim_{h\to0} \frac{-A(m_0,x_0+h)+A(m_0,x_0)}{h}.$$

The last term is equal, also by the definition partial derivative, to $- \partial_2 A(m_0,x_0)$.

Thus :

$$\partial_1 A(x_0,m_0)=- \partial_2 A(m_0,x_0)$$

1
On

Another way to look at this is to note that the function $B(x,m):=A(x,m)-\tfrac12$ is antisymmetric; $$B(x,m)=A(x,m)-\tfrac12=(1-A(m,x))-\tfrac12=\tfrac12-A(m,x)=-B(m,x).$$ What does that tell you about the partial derivatives?