Does existence and continuity of partial derivatives imply differentiability in Normed Vector Spaces?

89 Views Asked by At

I'm wondering if the 'Normed Vector Space version' of the following theorem holds:

Theorem: let $A\subseteq \mathbb{R}^n$ be open and let $f:A\to \mathbb{R}^m$ have continuous partial derivatives $\partial f_i/\partial x_j$ on $A$. Then $f$ is differentiable on $A$.


In particular, the total derivative can be extended to NVS by considering the Fréchet Derivative. If we extend the definition of partial derivatives as follows:

Throughout the post let $V$ and $W$ be NVSs, with $V'\subseteq V$ open and $f$ a function $V'\to W$.

Definition: given $a\in V'$ and a vector $v\in V$, we define (assuming the limit exists) $$\frac{\partial f}{\partial v}(a) := \lim_{t\rightarrow 0}\frac{f(a+tv)-f(a)}{t},$$

and, in the case $v=e_i$ for a basis vector $e_i$,

$$\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_i}(a) := \frac{\partial f}{\partial e_i}(a).$$

then, is either of the following statements true?

Theorem (?): if $f:V'\to W$ has continuous partial derivatives $\partial f/\partial v$ (for any $v\in V$) on $A$, then $f$ is differentiable on $A$.

Theorem (?): let $\dim V = n$ and $\dim W = m$. If $f:V'\to W$ have continuous partial derivatives $\partial f_i/\partial x_j$ on $A$, then $f$ is differentiable on $A$.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Here is an example which (if correct, please check) shows that the first conjecture is not true.

Let $V=c_0(\mathbb{N},\mathbb{R})$ endowed with the maximum norm $\|\cdot\|$ and consider $f=(f_n):V \to V$ defined as $$ f(x)=\left(\frac{1}{n}\sin(nx_n)\right) \quad (x=(x_n)\in V). $$ Fix any $v=(v_n) \in V$ and let $x=(x_n) \in V$. Note that for each $n$ $$ \frac{d}{dt}\frac{1}{n}\sin(n(x_n+tv_n)) = \cos(n(x_n+tv_n))v_n, $$ hence by the mean value theorem $$ \frac{1}{n}\sin(n(x_n+tv_n)) - \frac{1}{n}\sin(nx_n) = \cos(n(x_n+\tau_n(t)v_n))v_n t $$ for some $\tau_n(t)$ between $0$ and $t$, so $|\tau_n(t)| \le |t|$.

Let $\varepsilon > 0$. Choose $n_0 \in \mathbb{N}$ such that $|v_n| \le \varepsilon/3$ $(n \ge n_0+1)$. Now $$ \|\frac{f(x+tv)-f(x)}{t} - (\cos(nx_n)v_n)\| = \| (\cos(n(x_n+\tau_n(t)v_n))v_n- \cos(nx_n)v_n)\| $$ $$ \le \max_{n=1,\dots, n_0} | \cos(n(x_n+\tau_n(t)v_n))v_n- \cos(nx_n)v_n)| + 2\frac{\varepsilon}{3} $$ Since $\tau_n(t) \to 0$ $(t \to 0)$ for each $n$ there is some $\delta >0$ such that $$ \max_{n=1,\dots, n_0} | \cos(n(x_n+\tau_n(t)v_n))v_n- \cos(nx_n)v_n)| \le \frac{\varepsilon}{3} \quad (0<|t|< \delta). $$ Summing up $$ \|\frac{f(x+tv)-f(x)}{t} - (\cos(nx_n)v_n)\| \le \varepsilon \quad (0<|t|< \delta). $$ Thus $$ \frac{\partial f}{\partial v}(x)= (\cos(nx_n)v_n). $$ For each fixed $v$ (w.l.o.g $v\not=0$) the function $x \mapsto (\cos(nx_n)v_n)$ is continuous on $V$: Let $\varepsilon > 0$ and again let $n_0 \in \mathbb{N}$ be such that $|v_n| \le \varepsilon/3$ $(n \ge n_0+1)$. For $x,y \in V$ we have $$ \|(\cos(ny_n)v_n)-(\cos(nx_n)v_n)\| = \max_{n=1,\dots, n_0}|\cos(ny_n)v_n-\cos(nx_n)v_n| + 2\frac{\varepsilon}{3} $$ $$ \le n_0 \|x-y\| \|v\| + 2\frac{\varepsilon}{3}. $$ If $x$ is fixed then for each $y$ with $\|x-y\| \le \varepsilon/(3n_0 \|v\|)$ we have $$ \|(\cos(ny_n)v_n)-(\cos(nx_n)v_n)\| \le \varepsilon. $$ Finally we show that $f$ is not Frechet differentiable in $0=(0)$: Assume that $f$ is Frechet differentiable in $0$. Then $f'(0)h=(\cos(n0)h_n)=(h_n)$ $(h \in V)$, thus $f'(0)=id_V$. Now consider the sequence $h^{(k)} := \frac{2\pi}{k}e_k \in V$ (with $e_k=(\delta_{nk})$). Then $f(h^{(k)})=0$ for each $k$ and $\|h^{(k)}\| \to 0$ $(k \to \infty)$. Hence $$ 1=\frac{\|f(h^{(k)})-f(0)-h^{(k)}\|}{\|h^{(k)}\|} \to 0 \quad (k \to \infty), $$ a contradiction.