Equivalence of definitions of torsors in categories

145 Views Asked by At

I'm reading the nlab entry on torsors and am struggling to show the two definitions below are equivalent using only universal properties. All torsors in question are over a point.

Definition 1. A $G$-torsor is a $G$-action $\varphi:G\curvearrowright X$ which is isomorphic as an action to multiplication $m:G\curvearrowright G$.

Definition 2. A $G$-torsor is a $G$-action $\varphi:G\curvearrowright X$ such that $X$ admits a global point $x:\mathbf 1\to X$ and the arrow $(\varphi,\pi_2):G\times X\to X\times X$ is an isomorphism.

Given the first definition I thought of showing that $(m,\pi_2):G\times G\to G\times G$ is an isomorphism iff $(\varphi,\pi_2):G\times X\to X\times X$ is an isomorphism, since the latter is always an iso, but I don't know how to show this.

For the converse, for instance here, the nlab assumes the second definition and says the following square is a pullback, but I don't understand why. The "elements" of the pullback are triples $(g,x,y)$ such that $gx=y$ and saying this is the same as giving $G$ seems to assume we're already dealing with a $G$-torsor. $$\require{AMScd} \begin{CD} G\times \mathbf 1 @>{1\times x}>> G\times X\\ @VVV @VV{(\varphi,\pi_2)}V\\ X\times \mathbf 1 @>>{1\times x}> X\times X \end{CD}$$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

I did not check everything properly, so I hope nothing is wrong in the following. I will head back here tonight if time permits to be a little more precise.


Defn 1 $\implies$ Defn 2. Call $f$ the iso $G \to X$; show that indeed $(m,\pi_2)$ is an iso and that there is a global element in $G$ (namely its unit); post/pre-compose by $f$ and $f^{-1}$ to get back the same properties on $X$ and $\varphi$.

Defn 2 $\implies$ Defn 1. Try defining $f : G \to X$ as the composite $$ G \simeq G \times 1 \stackrel{{\rm id}\times x} \to G\times X \stackrel \varphi \to X $$ and show it has the following as inverse: $$ X \simeq X \times 1 \stackrel{{\rm id}\times x} \to X\times X \stackrel {(\varphi,\pi_2)^{-1}} \to G \times X \stackrel {\pi_1} \to G $$