Every element of the uniformity include a cube of a symmetric element

67 Views Asked by At

The following questions is from the book "General Topology" written by John L.Kelly and located in Page 179 in the proof of Thm 6.6.

Given ($X, \tau$), for definition of uniform space built up from $X$ and the uniform topology, please refer to the wiki link.

Given ($X, \tau$) and its uniformity $U_X$, define a product "$\circ$" between two elements in $U_X$ by

$U \circ V =$ {($x, z$)|$\exists y \in X$ such that ($x, y) \in U$ and ($y, z) \in V$} and by saying "$U$ cube", I mean $U \circ U \circ U$.

For any $U \in U_X$, define $U^{-1}$ = {($y, z$)|($x, y$) $\in U$}. An element $U \in U_X$ is symmetric iff $U$ = $U^{-1}$.

Once we have ($X, \tau$), $U_X$ and the uniform topology (say $\tau_{U}$), we can equip $X \times X$ with the product uniform topology.

Used facts:

  1. Thm 6.4 on Page 178: If we equip $X$ with the uniform topology, then the interior of $A \subset X$ is {$x \in X$|$\exists U \in U_X$ such that $U[x] \subset A$}

  2. Lemma 6.1 on Page 176: If $V$ is symmetric, then $V \circ U \circ V$ = $\cup${$V[x] \times V[y]$|($x, y$) $\in U$}

Below I will present the complete proof of Thm 6.

Thm 6: Let ($X, \tau$) be a topological space and define $U_X$ to be $X$'s uniformity. Let $U$ be an element of $U_X$ and then show that the interior of $U$ (relative to the uniform topology) is also a member of $U_X$. Consequently the family of all open symmetric members of $U_X$ is a base for $U_X$.

Proof: Equip $X \times X$ with the product uniform topology and the interior of a subset $M$ of $X \times X$ is the set of all ($x, y$) such that, for some $U$ and some $V$ in $U_X$, $U[x] \times V[x] \subset M$. Since $U \cap V \in U_X$, the interior of $M$ is {($x, y$)|$V[x] \times V[y] \subset M$}. If $U \in U_X$ there is a symmetric member $V \in U_X$ such that "$V$ cube" $\subset M$ and then by lemma 6.1, $V$ cube = $\cup${$V[x] \times V[y]$|($x, y$) $\in V$}. Hence, every point of $V$ is an interior point of $U$ and, since the interior of $U$ contains $V$, it is a member of $U_X$.

Here the bold sentence in the proof is where I get confused. Please believe that before Thm 6.6, there are no proofs for this statement and how can I prove that for any $U \in U_X$ there is a symmetric $V \in U_X$ such that "$V$ cube" $\subset U$.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

In the list of axioms that you link to, say $U$ is in the uniformity, then by axiom 4 there is $V$ (all sets listed will be in the uniformity) such that $V^2\subseteq U$. By axioms 5 and 3 we have that $V\cap V^{-1}$ is in the uniformity, so we may replace $V$ with $V\cap V^{-1}$, the latter set is symmetric, and so we may assume there is a symmetric $V$ with $V^2\subseteq U$. Could you push this a bit further, to get that there is a symmetric set in the uniformity say $W$, such that $W^3\subseteq U$?

Hint. Try $W^2\subseteq V$.