Expected value problem on dice reroll

519 Views Asked by At

The question is here:

Roll N* 3-sided dice(0,0,1), roll them twice and choose a better result, what is the expected value?

If possible I would also like an answer for dice {0,1,2} or {1,2,3} if that matters

Edited:

Since I am not very sure about probabilities, I'm not sure my attempt is correct or not.

I tried to observe the case when the final result is 0: $P[0]=(\frac23)^{2N}$

When final result is 1, that is we get result 0,1 unordered. The probabilities should be something like:

$$P[1]=(\frac13)^{2N}*(_NC_1*2^{2N})$$

and hence by guessing I suspect with something similar to induction we could prove the probability on getting final result k(<=N)should be something like

$$P[k]=(\frac13)^{2N}*(_NC_k*2^{2(N-k)}]$$

and I stucked here. I think, if we can get this, then the expected result could be:

$$E = 3^{2N} * \sum_0^N (k*P[k]) = \sum_0^N (k*_NC_k*2^{2(N-k)})$$

but I'm not sure whether the logic flow is correct or not, as I didn't study probability in my college, and sorry for my formatting.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

2
On

For the original question, you expect $\frac N3\ 1$'s on the first roll. You reroll the rest and expect $\frac {2N}9\ 1$'s for a total of $\frac {5N}9\ 1$'s For the second part, first notice that $\{0,1,2\}$ and $\{1,2,3\}$ are the same question-just add one to the values from the first to get the second. You need to specify whether you reroll the middle number, but the approach is the same. You expect $\frac N3$ of the top number and evenly distribute the rerolled dice.

0
On

Now I have another approach which involve no guessing. I get the probability of result exactly k by the difference of result <=k & result <= k-1, since by inspection <=k is very easy by counting, the difference is easy to get and hence getting the expected value easily.

However I'm still unsure how exactly <=k is done by counting, I just assumed it is a sequence on k and continue my work with it. Could anybody ensure me about this here?

Proof