Find the number of solutions for the equation $4\{x\}=x+[x]$

462 Views Asked by At

$$4\{x\}=[x]+\{x\}+[x]$$

$$3\{x\}=2[x]$$

$$\{x\}=\frac 23 [x]$$

$$0\le \frac 23 [x] <1$$

$$0\le [x]<1.5$$ So $[x]=0,1$

The solutions for $x$ should be infinite, but the given answer is 3.

Even if assume that the answer not being $\infty$ is upto interpretation, I still get only 2 as the answer. Please verify this solution.

The brackets represent fractional part and greatest integer part

4

There are 4 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Let $x=I+f$, with $I \in \Bbb{Z}$ and $0 \leq f <1$. Then we have $3f=2I$. Thus $f=0,\frac{2}{3}$ for $I=0,1$ respectively.

Thus only two solutions $0,1+\frac{2}{3}=\frac{5}{3}$.

0
On

Using ${x}=x-[x]$, thee equation reduces to $$ [x]=\frac 35 x$$Now, $$x-1\le [x]\le x \\ \implies x-1\le \frac 35 x\le x \\ \implies 0\le x\le \frac 52$$We must also have $\frac 35x\in \mathbb Z$, and from here it is easy to deduce that $x=0$ and $x=\frac 53$ are the only solutions.

0
On

Did you try to plot? $$0\{x\}=x-[x]\to \\ 4\{x\}=x+[x]\\ 4(x-[x])=x+[x]\\4x-x=4[x]+[x]\\\frac{3}{5}x=[x]$$set $f(x)=\frac35 x$,$f(x)=[x]$plot them togheter ,you will see two solution, x=0 is trivial, (and) by considering the slope the other one is crosssection of $[x]=1,\frac35x=1$ so $x=\frac 53$
if you put $x=\frac 53\to \{x\}=\frac23, [x]=1$ you will have $$4\times \frac 23=\frac53+1\checkmark$$

0
On

I'll try to solve this from where you left.

You have rightly shown that:

$[x] =0,1$ whence you try to conclude that no. of solutions of the given equation is infinite (You thought so probably because $[x] =0\implies 0\le x\lt 1$.) That is wrong because you have only found $[x] $ and not $x$. In order to find $x$, you need $\{x\} $ also so that $x=[x] +\{x\} $.

Therefore, you actually want to find $x=y$ such that "$[y] =0$ and $4\{y\}=y+[y]$" or "$[y] =1$ and $4\{y\}=y+[y]$"

Case 1:$[y] =0$
$4\{y\}=y+[y]=y\implies 4\{y\}=\{y\}+[y]=\{y\}\implies \{y\} =0\implies y=\{y\} +[y] =0$

Case 2: $[y] =1$
$4\{y\}=y+[y] =y+1=\{y\}+2\implies 3\{y\}=2\implies y=\{y\}+[y]=2/3 +1=5/3$

Therefore, $\exists$only two solutions viz. $x=0$ and $x=5/3$.