finding the unspecified ${\bf E}[X]$ and $\rm var(X)$ given the expectation of higher powers of $X$

113 Views Asked by At

Homework Problem:

It is known that a for a standard normal random variable $X$, we have ${\bf E}[X^3]=0$, ${\bf E}[X^4]=3$, ${\bf E}[X^5]=0$, ${\bf E}[X^6]=15$. Find the correlation coefficient between $X$ and $X^3$.

Answer:

Since ${\bf E}[X]={\bf E}[X^3]=0$, we have ${\rm cov}(X,X^3)={\bf E}[X\cdot X^3]={\bf E}[X^4]=3$. Furthermore, since ${\rm var}(X)=1$ and ${\rm var}(X^3)={\bf E}[X^6]=15$, we obtain $\rho (X,X^3)=\frac{3}{\sqrt {1}\cdot \sqrt {15}} =\sqrt {3/5}.$

Interestingly, even though the random variables are strongly dependent (the value of one determines the value of the other), the value of the correlation coefficient is moderate.


My approach was to try to solve for ${\bf E}[X]$ by calculating the covariance between various powers of $X$, but I couldn't come up with a way to isolate either ${\bf E}[X]$ or ${\rm var}(X)$.

The answer doesn't explain this. How is it determined that ${\bf E}[X]={\bf E}[X^3]=0$ and that ${\rm var}(X)=1$?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Yes, it being a standard normal implies that $EX=0$ and $VX=1$. But even without that knowledge you could have figured it out since

$$0=EX^3= E(X-\mu)^3 + 3 \mu E(X-\mu)^2 + 3 \mu^2 E(X-\mu) + \mu^3 = 3\mu\sigma^2 + \mu^3,$$

such that $\mu=0$ or $\mu^2=3\sigma^2$.

Further,

$$3=EX^4= E(X-\mu)^4 + 4 \mu E(X-\mu)^3 + 6 \mu^2 E(X-\mu)^2 + 4 \mu^3 E(X-\mu)+\mu^4 \\ = 3\sigma^4 + 6 \mu^2 \sigma^2 + \mu^4,$$

etcetera.