Forced nonlinear oscillator - analytical methods

694 Views Asked by At

This is an example from Kovacic & Brennan (2011). Consider the following equation of motion for a forced, non-linear oscillator (Duffing's equation):

$$ \ddot x + 2 \zeta \dot x + \alpha x + \gamma x^3 = F \cos \Omega t, $$ where $\zeta, \alpha, \gamma, F$ and $\Omega$ are parameters. We assume "the steady-state harmonic solution" as

$$ x = Y\cos{(\Omega t - \theta)}. $$

My goal is to obtain the following equation for $Y$:

$$ Y^2 = \frac{F^2}{4\zeta^2\Omega^2 + \left( \Omega^2 - \alpha - % \frac{3}{4}\gamma Y^2 \right)^2}. $$

This is done by 1) substituting the second equation into the first, and 2) equating the coefficients of $\sin\Omega t$ and $\cos\Omega t$ from both sides.

The substitution part seems straightforward, but I can't quite wrap my head around the last step. Especially the "$\cos(\Omega t-\theta)$" on the right hand side is causing headaches.

Suggestions are welcome!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

8
On BEST ANSWER

This problem is simple differentiation and substitution...except that the cubic term makes things a little hairy. First thing is to expand the cosine term as

$$\cos{(\Omega t-\theta)} = \cos{\Omega t} \cos{\theta} + \sin{\Omega t} \sin{\theta}$$

Now differentiate and plug in. The linear terms involving the derivative are simple and I'll just list them here:

$$\ddot{x} + 2 \zeta \dot{x} + \alpha x = Y \left [ \left ( -\Omega^2 \cos{\theta} - 2 \zeta \Omega \sin{\theta} + \alpha \cos{\theta} \right ) \cos{\Omega t} \\+ \left (-\Omega^2 \sin{\theta} + 2 \zeta \Omega \cos{\theta} + \alpha \sin{\theta} \right ) \sin{\Omega t} \right ] $$

The cubic piece is expanded as usual:

$$\gamma x^3 = \gamma Y^3 (\cos^3{\Omega t} \cos^3{\theta} + 3 \cos^2{\Omega t} \sin{\Omega t} \cos^2{\theta} \sin{\theta} + 3 \sin^2{\Omega t} \cos{\Omega t} \sin^2{\theta} \cos{\theta}+ \sin^3{\Omega t} \sin^3{\theta}$$

Now we do not want powers of the sines and cosines, but rather linear terms. Use the fact that

$$\cos{3 y} = 4 \cos^3{y} - 3 \cos{y}$$ $$\sin{3 y} = 3 \sin{y} - 4 \sin^3{y}$$

and, doing some rearranging, get that

$$\gamma x^3 = \gamma Y^3 \left [\frac{3}{4} \cos{\theta} \cos{\Omega t} + \frac{3}{4} \sin{\theta} \sin{\Omega t} \\+ \frac{1}{4} \cos{\theta}\left (\cos^2{\theta} - 3 \sin^2{\theta} \right ) \cos{3 \Omega t} + \frac{1}{4} \sin{\theta}\left (3 \cos^2{\theta}-\sin^2{\theta} \right ) \sin{3 \Omega t} \right ]$$

Note that the $3 \Omega$ terms represent the frequency multiplication induced by nonlinear terms. We will ignore these terms because...(e.g., $\gamma$ is small, etc. etc.). What we are left with is

$$Y \left [ \left ( \left (\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2\right ) \cos{\theta} - 2 \zeta \Omega \sin{\theta} \right ) \cos{\Omega t} \\+ \left ( \left (\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2\right ) \sin{\theta} + 2 \zeta \Omega \cos{\theta} \right ) \sin{\Omega t} \right ] = F \cos{\Omega t}$$

Now we simply eliminate $\theta$ by setting the coefficient of $\sin{\Omega t}$ to zero:

$$\left (\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2\right ) \sin{\theta} + 2 \zeta \Omega \cos{\theta} =0$$

or

$$\tan{\theta} = -\frac{ 2 \zeta \Omega}{\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2}$$

which means that, to within a sign,

$$\cos{\theta} = \frac{\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2}{\sqrt{4 \zeta^2 \Omega^2 + \left (\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2 \right )^2}} $$

$$\sin{\theta} = -\frac{2 \zeta \Omega}{\sqrt{4 \zeta^2 \Omega^2 + \left (\alpha-\Omega^2 + \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2 \right )^2}} $$

and therefore, plugging these values into the equation for the coefficient of $\cos{\Omega t}$, we get that, within a sign:

$$Y = \frac{F}{\sqrt{4 \zeta^2 \Omega^2 + \left (\Omega^2 -\alpha - \frac{3}{4} \gamma Y^2 \right )^2}} $$

The posted equation for $Y$ follows.