Gradient vector $\nabla F = (z_x, z_y, -1)$ is normal to the integral surface?

295 Views Asked by At

I have an integral surface $z = z(x, y)$.

Writing this integral surface in implicit form, we get

$$F(x, y, z) = z(x, y) - z = 0$$

I am then told that the gradient vector $\nabla F = (z_x, z_y, -1)$ is normal to the integral surface $F(x, y, z) = 0$.

First of all, how was this calculated? I understand how the gradient is calculated, but I don't understand how it was calculated in this case?

And lastly, where did the $-1$ come from and why? Couldn't they also have had $\nabla F = (z_x, z_y, 1)$, where this would just be the normal vector in the other direction? Why and how did they pick the $-1$ direction instead?

I apologise. My vector calculus understanding is not particularly strong, and I strive to improve it.

Thank you for any help.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

maybe its helpful to give the surface equation a different symbol $$ S = \{ (x,y,z) : z=Z(x,y) \}$$ then with $F(x,y,z):= Z(x,y) - z$,

$$∇ F (x,y,z) = \begin{pmatrix}\partial_x( Z(x,y) - z)\\\partial_y( Z(x,y) - z)\\\partial_z( Z(x,y) - z)\end{pmatrix}= \begin{pmatrix}\partial_x Z(x,y)\\\partial_yZ(x,y)\\\ - 1\end{pmatrix}$$ The $-1$ came from the definition of $F$. If you forced $+1$ instead of $-1$ you would be talking about $Z(x,y) + z$ which is not related to $S = \{F = 0 \}$.

If you take any curve $\mathbf x=\mathbf x(t)$ such that $\mathbf x(t) ∈ S$ for every $t$, then

$$ F(\mathbf x(t)) = 0 $$ taking derivatives, $$∇ F(\mathbf x)· \mathbf x' = 0$$ but the collection of all such $\mathbf x'$s as you consider different curves $\mathbf x$ form the tangent vectors at each point of $S$. Therefore, $∇ F$ is perpendicular to all tangent vectors of $S$ at that point. In dimension 3, there are 2 linearly independent tangent vectors and you get a unique normal vector (up to scaling and sign).

4
On

Let us start with an example.

$$ z=x^2+y^2$$ $$ F(x,y,z)=x^2+y^2-z$$ $$\nabla F = (z_x, z_y, -1)=< 2x,2y,-1>$$

If a point is given, for example $P(1,2,5)$ Then at that point you have two normal vector to the surface.

Upward normal $$< -2x,-2y,1> = <-2,-4,1>$$ Downward normal $$< 2x,2y,-1> = <2,4,-1>$$