Having trouble with question involving percentiles and symmetry

846 Views Asked by At

A large university will begin a $13$-day period during which students may register for that semester’s courses. Of those $13$ days, the number of elapsed days before a randomly selected student registers has a continuous distribution with density function $f(t)$ that is symmetric about $t = 6.5$ and proportional to $1 \over t+1$ between days $0$ and $6.5.$ A student registers at the $60$th percentile of this distribution. Calculate the number of elapsed days in the registration period for this student.

The constant of proportionality is $.5\over ln7.5$,

So I thought you should do $${\int^x_0}{.5\over ln7.5}{1\over t+1}dt=.6$$

$${.5\over ln7.5}ln(x+1)-{.5\over ln7.5}ln(0+1)=.6$$

Which comes out to $x+1=e^\left({.6{ln7.5\over.5}}\right)$

However the real solution says you should do

$${\int^{13-x}_0}{.5\over ln7.5}{1\over t+1}dt=.4$$

$${.5\over ln7.5}ln(13-x+1)-{.5\over ln7.5}ln(0+1)=.4$$

Which comes out to $14-x=e^\left({.4{ln7.5\over.5}}\right)$ (a different number than my solution.)

If I understand correctly, the rationale behind the correct solution is that since there is a symmetry, the first 4oth percentile is the same as the last, which is the 60th percentile. I just don't understand why my way is not correct.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

The symmetry of the pdf means that after between 6.5 and 13 days the pdf is actually .. $${.5\over ln7.5}{1\over (13-t)+1} $$ you could get the correct answer by noting that $x>6.5$ so $${\int^{6.5}_0}{.5\over ln7.5}{1\over t+1}dt + {\int^{x}_{6.5}}{.5\over ln7.5}{1\over 14-t}dt =.6 \\ \implies {\int^{x}_{6.5}}{.5\over ln7.5}{1\over 14-t}dt =.1 $$