Help proving vector spaces given operation

23 Views Asked by At

I have this exercise that asks me to prove the set V=R is a vector space.

Operations are

$ x \oplus y = \sqrt[3]{x^3+y^3} $

and

$ c \otimes x = \sqrt[3]{c*x} $

I already proved all axioms until Distributive I'm getting a bit confused here, do i have to consider $ \otimes $ and $ \oplus$ as operations always ? (except for under the root)

For example, can i do this ?

$ c \otimes (x + y) = \\ \sqrt[3]{c*(x+y)} = \\ \sqrt[3]{c*x + c*y} $

As you see i used $\otimes$ and normal +

Or is this the right way ?

$ (c \otimes x) \oplus (c \otimes y) = \\ \sqrt[3]{c*x} \oplus \sqrt[3]{c*y} = \\ \sqrt[3]{(\sqrt[3]{c*x})^3 + (\sqrt[3]{c*y})^3} = \\ \sqrt[3]{c*x + c*y} $


AND

$ c \otimes (x \oplus y) =\\ \sqrt[3]{c*(x\oplus y)} = \\ \sqrt[3]{c*x \oplus c*y} \\ \sqrt[3]{\sqrt[3]{(c*x)^3 + (c*y)^3}}$


In this case distribution seems not to work as $\sqrt[3]{\sqrt[3]{(cx)^3 + (cy)^3}}$ is not equal to $\sqrt[3]{cx + cy}$

Can someone help me do distribution the right way ? Thank you

2

There are 2 best solutions below

3
On

You have copied the definition wrongly. The correct definition of $c \otimes x$ is $c \otimes x=(\sqrt [3] c)x$.

0
On

My solution after question correction

enter image description here