Help with Harshorne Example II 6.5.2 on the Weil divisor class group of the affine cone

66 Views Asked by At

The example is about computing the Weil divisor class group of the affine cone Spec$k[x,y,z]/ \langle xy-z^2\rangle$.

I can show that the group is cyclic generated by the divisor $V(y,z )$ and that this is principle in order $2$, so it remains to show that the divisor $V(y,z)$ is not itself principal.

Hartshorne says

since $A$ is integrally closed, it is equivalent to show that the prime ideal of $Y$, namely $\mathfrak{p} = \langle y,z \rangle $ is not principal.

My problem is that I don't see why being integrally closed makes these two things equivalent.

Suppose $A$ is an integrally closed domain and let $Z$ be a principal prime Weil divisor with generic point $\mathfrak{p}$. Then there is an element $f \in K(A)$ such that $f$ generates the maximal ideal $\mathfrak{p}A_{\mathfrak{p}}$ in $A_{\mathfrak{p}}$. Moreover, $f$ lies in the other local rings $A_{\mathfrak{q}}$ whenever $\mathfrak{q}$ has height $1$. So since $A$ is integrally closed, this gives us that $f \in A$. But I don't see how this is equivalent to showing that $f$ generates $\mathfrak{p}$.

I try to show this: Certainly $\frac{f}{1}$ generates $\mathfrak{p}A_{\mathfrak{p}}$ by assumption. So let $x \in \mathfrak{p}$. We want to be able to write $x$ as a multiple of $f$. In the local ring, $\frac{f}{1}\cdot \frac{a}{s} = \frac{x}{1}$. Since $A$ is a domain, this gives us that $fa = sx$, which is not sufficient to show that $f$ generates $\mathfrak{p}$.

Is someone able to point me in the right direction?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Two crucial facts you haven't used yet: $v_p(f) = 1$ and $v_q(f) = 0$ for all height 1 prime ideals $q \neq p$.

Now, let $q$ be a height one prime prime ideal, and we have $v_q(f) + v_q(a) = v_q(s) + v_q(x)$. Since $v_q(x) \geq 0$ and $v_q(f) = 0$, we have $v_q(a) \geq v_q(s)$

For $p$, we have $1 + v_p(a) = v_p(x)$. Since $v_p(s) = 0$ and $v_p(x) \geq 1$, $v_p(a) \geq 0 = v_p(s)$

Therefore, $div(a/s) \geq 0$ so $a/s \in A$. Your equation is now $f * \frac{a}{s} = x$ which takes place in $A$ (here we use that $A$ is an integral domain, so $A \rightarrow A_p$ is injective)

See the proof of proposition 6.2 and adapt it to this case.