How to determine intervals where $f$ is greater than $g$?

1.1k Views Asked by At

I have two functions, $f(x) = 2x$ and $g(x) = \frac{x^3}{3}$. I solved for $x$ where $f = g$, finding $x = \pm 6^{1/2}$, then solved for $x$ where $f > g$, $x > \pm 6^{1/2}$, and where $f < g$, $x < \pm 6^{1/2}$. However it is clear there is overlap for where I have stated $f > g$ and $f < g$. How do I show that $f > g$ only when $x \in (0, 6^{1/2})$ and $f < g$ only when $x \in (- 6^{1/2}, 0)$ without graphing?

Completely different approaches from mine are welcomed!

3

There are 3 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

Solve the inequality $$ 2x>\frac{x^3}{3} $$ that can be rewritten as $$ x(x-\sqrt{6})(x+\sqrt{6})<0 $$ The expression on the left changes sign only at $-\sqrt{6}$, $0$ and $\sqrt{6}$ (where it vanishes). Since its value at $1$ is $-5$ you have the diagram $$ \begin{array}{ccccccc} \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & -\sqrt{6} & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & 0 & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & \sqrt{6} & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ \\ & & & & <0 & \end{array} $$ and you can complete it by changing sign at the stated points $$ \begin{array}{ccccccc} \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & -\sqrt{6} & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & 0 & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ & \sqrt{6} & \_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_\!\_ \\ <0 & =0 & >0 & =0 & <0 & =0 & >0 \end{array} $$ So the intervals where the original inequality holds are $(-\infty,-\sqrt{6})$ and $(0,\sqrt{6})$.

0
On

The roots, $x = 0, -\sqrt{6}, +\sqrt{6}$ show merely the crossover points. You must test the four regions defined by those three points:

  • $-\infty < x \leq -\sqrt{6}$
  • $-\sqrt{6} \leq x \leq 0$
  • $0 \leq x \leq +\sqrt{6}$
  • $\sqrt{6} \leq x < \infty$
2
On

You forgot the solution $x=0$.

By the Intermediate Value theorem the relative positions of the curves can change only at intersection points. Now, for $x\gg 1$, $f(x)<g(x)$, hence we conclude

  • if $x>\sqrt 6$, $f(x)<g(x)$,
  • if $0<x<\sqrt 6$, $f(x)>g(x)$,
  • if $-\sqrt 6<x< $, $f(x)<g(x)$,
  • if $x<-\sqrt 6$, $f(x)>g(x)$.