In a cournot's duopoly with firms 'A' and 'B' given the following conditions what are the strategies(output) that 'A' never chooses.

71 Views Asked by At

The total output is given by $$ \left(1-\frac{1}{N+1} \right)\frac{a-c}{b}$$ with $N=2$. The inverse demand function is $P=a-bx$ with $a=5, b=1, c=2$, where $x$ is the total output and $c$ is the cost which is a constant.

Firms 'A' and 'B' are both rational and Firm 'A' knows that firm 'B' is rational

The possible strategies(output) for 'A' are $Q_a=\{0,0.25,0.5,0.75,1,1.25,1.5,1.75,2\}$. Which of these is never chosen by 'A'? what I have done

2

There are 2 best solutions below

6
On

Although, the equilibrium quantity for both the firms comes out to be $Q_A^*=Q_B^*=\frac53$ as in your attempt, this does not agree with the bound that is imposed on the total quantity.

$Q_T = Q_A + Q_B= 2$

Neither firm $A$ nor firm $B$ would choose on an output greater than half of the total quantity. So that, $Q_A \le 1$ and $Q_B \le 1$.

The profit equation for firm $A$ is:

$\pi = (5-(Q_A+Q_B))Q_A - 2 = (5-2) Q_A -2 = 3Q_A -2$

The profit cannot be less than zero, so we get a lower bound:

$\pi \ge 0 \implies Q_A \ge \frac23$

Since, $\frac23 \le Q_A \le 1$

$Q_A \in \{0.75,1\}$

0
On

$$Q^*_A = \frac{5-Q_B}{2}$$

$$Q^*_B = \frac{5-Q_A}{2}$$

Using IEDS (iterative elimination of dominant strategy) method,

$\text{Step 1}$

Note that $Q^*_A \le \frac52$ since $Q_B \ge 0$

Similarly, $Q^*_B \le \frac52$ since $Q_A \ge 0$

$\text{Step 2}$

Since, $Q^*_B \le \frac52$, and Firm $A$ knows that Firm $B$ is rational,

$\implies\frac{5-Q_B}2 \ge \frac{5-\frac52}2$

$\implies Q^*_A \ge \frac54$

Since, Firm $B$ is not aware of $A$ being rational, this is where the iterative elimination ends.

$1.25 \le Q_A \le 2.5$

In case, it is not the total cost but the marginal cost that is constant (in which case, the reaction curves will change), we get

$0.9375 \le Q_A \le 1.25$