Intersection of two circles dividing lune in given ratio

580 Views Asked by At

If have two circles intersecting along their diameter, let $A,B$ with radius $r_1, r_2$ in the ratio of $1:n/2$ (for $n$ being a positive real number), and overlapping area is the same as radius of smaller circle (let, $r_1$); then how to prove geometrically that the lune formed will be having the intersection point (shown as point $H$, on the line joining the diameters) with length from the center of the smaller circle as : $\frac{r_1}{n}$. enter image description here

I can prove for different ratios of two circles individually and trying algebraically the two equations of different circles with diameters lying only on the $x$-axis.
Say, for ratio $n=5$, the two equations are given below with $b =r_1+2\cdot r_2$ being the total length of the two circles with intersecting length equal to $r_1$, assuming $r_1= \frac{b}{2^3}, r_2 = \frac{5r_1}{2}$ (or, diameter of circle $B=5r_1$) :
$$circle \,\,A :> (x-\frac{b}{8})^2 + y^2 = (\frac{b}{8})^2$$ $$circle \,\,B :> (x-\frac{7b}{16})^2 + y^2 = (\frac{5b}{16})^2$$

Have drawn at desmos too, the graph for the above at : https://www.desmos.com/calculator/e6dhp99eiu.
The graph also shows that the intersection point (shown by dotted line) is having length = $\frac{r_1}{5}$.

But a geometrical proof is needed.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

6
On BEST ANSWER

Using Andrei's notation:

enter image description here

Since $C_AK$ is a diameter, $$\angle C_AMK=90^\circ.$$ Hence $$\angle C_AMK = \angle C_AHM.$$

Also $\angle MC_AK = \angle HC_AM.$

Hence $\triangle C_AMK$ is similar to $\triangle C_AHM$, hence we have

$$\frac{C_AH}{C_AM}=\frac{C_AM}{C_AK}=\frac{r_1}{2r_2}=\frac{1}{n}$$

$$\frac{C_AH}{C_AM}=\frac{1}{n}$$

$$\frac{C_AH}{r_1}=\frac{1}{n}$$

$$C_AH=\frac{r_1}{n}$$

1
On

Let's call the upper intersection point $M$, and the two centers $C_A$ and $C_B$. The triangles $C_AMH$ and $C_BMH$ are right angle triangles, so we can write $MH$ from Pythagoras' theorem in each triangle: $$MH^2=C_AM^2-C_AH^2=C_BM^2-C_BH^2=C_BM^2-(C_AC_B-C_AH)^2$$ We notice that $C_BM=C_AC_B$, so from the second and fourth terms above $$C_AM^2-C_AH^2=C_AC_B^2-C_AC_B^2+2C_AC_B\cdot C_AH-C_AH^2\\ C_AM^2=2C_AC_B\cdot C_AH\\C_AH=\frac{C_AM^2}{2C_AC_B}=C_AM\frac{1}{2n/2}=\frac{r_1}{n}$$