Is $e^{i+\pi}$ irrational or not?

937 Views Asked by At

Since we know that the value of $e$, $i$, and $\pi$ are irrational reals, how about $$e^{i+\pi}\;?$$ Is it still irrational (that is, not a Gaussian rational)? The problem make me curious until now.

3

There are 3 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Building off of Clive's answer, if $e^\pi \cos 1$ and $e^\pi \sin 1$ were both rational numbers, then so would be their quotient $\tan 1$. But $\tan 1$ is irrational as a consequence of the Lindemann–Weierstrass theorem, because that theorem implies that $e^{2i}$ is transcendental, and because $e^{2i}=\dfrac{i-\tan 1}{\tan 1+i}$. Therefore $e^{\pi+i}$ cannot have both its real and imaginary parts rational.

10
On

$e^i=\cos1+i\sin1$. (By Euler's Formula)

So $e^{i+\pi}=e^\pi\cos1+ie^\pi\sin1$, which is non-real and, of course, irrational.

1
On

If you mean rational in the usual sense $-$ as a subset of the reals $-$ then $e^{i+\pi}$ is certainly not rational since it is not real. But the question of whether it's a Gaussian rational $-$ that is, its real and complex parts are rational $-$ may not be easy to prove. Notice that $$e^{i+\pi} = e^{\pi}\cos 1 + i e^{\pi}\sin 1$$

Given irrational numbers $\alpha$ and $\beta$ it's often quite hard to determine whether $\alpha^{\beta}$ and $\alpha \beta$ (and $\alpha + \beta$) are rational or irrational. For example, it is not currently known whether $e\pi$ is rational or irrational.