Is there a quick method to solve a problem involving guessing the correct weighs?

62 Views Asked by At

This is a problem I often see in exams, it involves calculating the least number of weighing operations needed to get the weight asked.

It states this:

Allison has a bag of rice which weighs more than 17 ounces and she has a two pan balance and 4 different weights being 3 oz, 4 oz, 7 oz and 11 oz respectively. How many times at least does she has to use the balance to get 17oz of rice?

I tried to solve this problem by summing up all the weighs:

$3\,\textrm{oz}+4\,\textrm{oz}+7\,\textrm{oz}+11\,\textrm{oz}=25\,\textrm{oz}$

Since what it is being asked is to get $17$ ounces what I tried to do is to find the possible combinations which put in each pan so that they sum up to 17.

But grouping either $11$ in one side and $3+4+7$ in the other the resulting weight is $3$. If I choose not to use one of the weights let's say $11$ and $4+7$ it cancels both sides, while $3+7$ produces $1$ ounce in the other side therefore it cannot be used, if it is $3+4$ it produces $4$ ounces. So it seems it is impossible to get the $17$ ounces at once.

The other choice would be just using in the first attempt just $3$ and $7$, and in the second turn just the weight of $7$ ounce. Therefore the least number of times to use the balance would be $2$. But this answer is not correct.

The method I tried to use I don't think it is right, it is prone to errors and more importantly is tedious which is something I can't use at an exam where time is limited.

Can somebody help me to find a more orderly and logical method step by step to solve these kind of problems other than just guessing and starting to plug in numbers randomly as if I was trying to hit a target?.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On

In this case trying to plug in numbers is the fastest way to solve this. Also keep in mind that you can put a weight together with the rice, effectively subtracting. The solution is thus:

$$11 + 7 + 3 - 4 = 17$$

9
On

Here's how I did it. First, I guessed that you had to use all the weights. Then I said suppose I put $x$ ounces in one pan and $y$ in the other. I want $$\begin{align} x+y&= 25\\ x-y&= 17 \end{align} $$ so $x=21$ and $y=4$.

This method isn't guaranteed to work, of course. It just checks whether it's possible to do it in one weighing by using all the weights.