Is this proof correct or am I trying to prove a falsehood?

63 Views Asked by At

Suppose that we have three possible outcomes $\alpha$, $\beta$ and $\gamma$ (if that helps, suppose they are monetary amounts) and some threshold $x$. Then, we also know that \begin{gather*} x\geqslant\alpha\\ x\geqslant\tau\beta+(1-\tau)\gamma \end{gather*} for any $\tau\in[0,1]$. My goal is to show that if the above Inequalities hold, then \begin{gather*} x\geqslant(1-\rho-\pi)\alpha+\rho\beta+\pi\gamma \end{gather*} for any $(\rho,\pi)\in[0,1]^2$ such that $\rho+\tau\in[0,1]$. My attempt is as follows. Let's go step by step.

  1. Given the premises, define some $\varphi\in[0,1]$ and then write \begin{gather*} x\geqslant\varphi\alpha+(1-\varphi)\left[\tau\beta+(1-\tau)\gamma\right] \end{gather*}

  2. Then, resolve some multiplications to get \begin{gather*} x\geqslant\varphi\alpha+(\tau-\varphi\tau)\beta+(1-\varphi\tau-\varphi-\tau)\gamma \end{gather*}

  3. Because $\tau\in[0,1]$ and $\varphi\in[0,1]$, it follows that \begin{gather*} 0\leqslant\tau-\varphi\tau\leqslant1\\ 0\leqslant1-\varphi\tau-\varphi-\tau\leqslant1 \end{gather*}

  4. Therefore, let $\rho=\tau-\varphi\tau$ and $\pi=1-\varphi\tau-\varphi-\tau$ and then write: \begin{gather*} x\geqslant\varphi\alpha+\rho\beta+\tau\gamma \end{gather*}

  5. Then, notice that \begin{align*} 1-\rho-\pi&=1-\tau+\varphi\tau-1-\varphi\tau+\varphi+\tau\\ &=1+\varphi-1\\ &=\varphi \end{align*}

  6. And voilà! It seems we're done, because \begin{gather*} x\geqslant(1-\rho-\pi)\alpha+\rho\beta+\pi\gamma \end{gather*}

Therefore, my question is: is this simple proof correct? If it is false, please state why; if it is true only under some unstated conditions, please state them. If it is correct... Well, then just say it.

Thank you all very much in advanced for your time and effort.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Plugging in $\tau = 1$ we get $x \ge \beta$, while plugging in $\tau = 0$ we get $x \ge \gamma$. Let $\delta = \max\{\alpha,\beta,\gamma\}$; then we have $x \ge \delta$. So, we have: \begin{align*} (1-\rho-\pi)\alpha + \rho\beta + \pi\gamma &\le (1 - \rho - \pi) \delta + \rho \delta + \pi \delta\\ &\le\delta\\ &\le x. \end{align*}